Pfaltzgraff Winterberry 32-Piece Dinnerware Set vs Everyday White Beaded 32-Piece Dinnerware Set

Buy the Winterberry set if you want a holiday table with serving pieces included and a pattern that has been a fixture since 1991. Buy the Everyday White Beaded set if you want plain white porcelain that goes from weeknight dinner to a formal table and can go in the oven. The Winterberry is stoneware and the Everyday White is porcelain, so the white set feels denser and heavier in the hand. Winterberry has far more owner feedback and a higher rating, but both sets draw complaints about chipped, broken or uneven pieces arriving.

• Choose the Winterberry if you host holiday meals and want a festive pattern plus a matching platter and vegetable bowl in the box.
• Choose the Everyday White Beaded if you want neutral white porcelain that works year-round and is oven safe to 450 degrees.