StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Columbia Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Jacket vs Mackage 3-in-1 Balmacaan Coat

The Columbia Amaze Puff is the practical pick for everyday winter wear: 650 fill power down, a removable hood, a stain-resistant waterproof shell and a fit cut for layering. The Mackage Balmacaan is the dressier option, a long tailored coat with a removable down liner and detachable hood that works over office and evening clothes. Columbia is the better value on warmth per dollar and easier to live in; Mackage wins on style and versatility across seasons.

  • Choose the Columbia Amaze Puff if you want a warm, waterproof everyday down jacket you can layer under and wear in snow and rain without worrying about it.
  • Choose the Mackage Balmacaan if you want a long, tailored coat that looks sharp over work clothes and converts to a lighter shell when the liner comes out.

Prices

  • Columbia Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Jacket: $220.00 at Backcountry (checked today)
  • Mackage 3-in-1 Balmacaan Coat: $1,290.00 at Mackage (checked today)
  • Difference: the Columbia Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Jacket is $1,070.00 cheaper than the Mackage 3-in-1 Balmacaan Coat today
Columbia Sportswear
Women's Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Insulated Waterproof Jacket

Columbia Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Jacket

Women's Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Insulated Waterproof Jacket

$220.00at BackcountryChecked 2 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Backcountry

Store links may earn us a commission. Price via Klarna.

Pros
  • 650 fill power down traps heat well
  • Waterproof and stain-resistant shell
  • Removable, adjustable hood
  • Regular fit leaves room for a sweater
  • Sporty quilted look suits casual wear
Cons
  • Short length leaves thighs exposed
  • Puffer silhouette is casual, not dressy
  • Down needs special care when washing
Mackage
Mackage 3-in-1 Balmacaan Coat With Removable Down Liner

Mackage 3-in-1 Balmacaan Coat

Mackage 3-in-1 Balmacaan Coat With Removable Down Liner

$1,290.00at MackageChecked 3 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Mackage

Store links may earn us a commission. Price via Klarna.

Pros
  • Long tailored cut looks polished
  • Removable down liner extends the wearing season
  • Detachable hood adds flexibility
  • Waterproof shell handles wet weather
Cons
  • Liner is lighter than a dedicated down jacket
  • Slim cut limits layering
  • Wool-blend fabric needs careful care

What separates them

Columbia Amaze Puff 3-in-1 JacketMackage 3-in-1 Balmacaan Coat
Length and silhouetteShort hip-length quilted puffer, 23 in center backLong balmacaan cut that falls past the hip
Insulation650 fill power down, fixedDown/feather fill in a removable liner
Versatility3-in-1 with removable hood; liner stays in3-in-1 with removable down liner and detachable hood
StyleSporty quilted outdoor lookTailored, dressier coat
Weather protectionWaterproof, stain-resistant nylon shellWaterproof shell
Fit for layeringRegular fit with room for a sweaterSlim tailored cut, less room underneath
Care and durabilityNylon shell resists stains and moisture, easy to wipe cleanWool-blend balmacaan needs more careful care
Warmth for deep coldDown jacket built for winterLiner is lighter; best for mild to moderate cold

Price history

$1,290.00$220.00
Nov 1Nov 17
  • Columbia Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Jacket: lowest $220.00 on Nov 1 at Amazon; $220.00 on Nov 17.
  • Mackage 3-in-1 Balmacaan Coat: lowest $1,290.00 on Nov 10 at Mackage; $1,290.00 on Nov 17.

Prices at every store

Columbia Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Jacket

  • BackcountryNew

    In stock

    $220.00Free shippingChecked 2 h ago
    Visit Backcountry
  • Going Going GoneNew

    In stock

    $220.00Free shippingChecked 2 h ago
    Visit Going Going Gone
  • ColumbiaNew

    In stock

    $220.00+ $6.00 shippingChecked 2 h ago
    Visit Columbia
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $220.00Free shippingChecked 3 h ago
    Visit Amazon

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

All 4 stores and price history →

Mackage 3-in-1 Balmacaan Coat

  • MackageNew

    In stock

    $1,290.00Free shippingChecked 3 h ago
    Visit Mackage

Store links may earn us a commission. Price via Klarna.

Prices and history →

Specs compared

SpecColumbia Amaze Puff 3-in-1 JacketMackage 3-in-1 Balmacaan Coat
PatternQuiltedSolid Color
ColorBlackBeige
Age GroupAdultAdult
FillingDown/Feather FillingDown/Feather Filling
SizePlease select a Size—
Regular FitUniversal, easy fit for comfortable range of mo…—
DurabilityRepels moisture, Resists stains—
SeasonWinter—
WarmthTraps more heat, 650 fill power down insulation—
Alpha SizeM, L, S, XL, XS—
Numeric Size8-10 (Women's Apparel, MD)—
Visual ColorHigh Shine—
Show all 32 specsShow fewer specs
SpecColumbia Amaze Puff 3-in-1 JacketMackage 3-in-1 Balmacaan Coat
Fabric Material100% Nylon (Shell)—
Fabric HighlightsMoisture-repelling finish—
FitRoom for layering a sweater or sweatshirt—
InsulatedYes—
Fill MaterialDown—
DepartmentWomen's—
GenderWomen—
ActivityEveryday—
Hood TypeRemovable, Drawcord-adjustable—
Occasion

What reviewers say

Mackage 3-in-1 Balmacaan Coat

Owners of Mackage coats tend to praise the tailoring, warmth and weather protection, and the 3-in-1 design draws positive notes for stretching one coat across seasons. Common complaints center on weight, the liner's bulk and the care the light color demands.

What people mention
  • VersatilityPraisedOwners like getting a fall shell and a winter down coat from one purchase.
  • WarmthPraisedThe down liner keeps wearers warm in cold city weather.
  • Weather protectionPraisedThe waterproof shell and hood handle rain and snow well.
  • WeightMixedSome find the coat heavy, especially with the liner in.

Questions and answers

Which is warmer in deep winter?
The Columbia Amaze Puff. Its fixed 650 fill power down is built for winter cold. The Mackage liner is lighter and better for mild to moderate cold.
Which is more versatile?
The Mackage. Its removable down liner and detachable hood let it work as a lighter shell in fall and spring. The Columbia's liner stays in.
Which looks better over work clothes?
The Mackage Balmacaan. Its long tailored cut reads dressier. The Columbia is a sporty quilted puffer.
Which handles rain and snow better?
Both are waterproof. The Columbia adds a stain-resistant finish and a nylon shell that wipes clean easily.
Is the Mackage worth stepping up to?
If you want one coat for office and evening wear, yes. If you need maximum warmth for cold commutes, the Columbia does more for less.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Women's Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Insulated Waterproof Jacket vs Patagonia Heyes Peak 3-in-1 Parka
  • Women's Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Insulated Waterproof Jacket vs Beverley Womens 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket
  • Women's Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Insulated Waterproof Jacket vs Women's 3 in 1 Plus Size Winter Coats Waterproof Ski Jacket Hooded Snowboarding Jacket
  • Patagonia Tres 3-in-1 Parka vs Women's Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Insulated Waterproof Jacket
  • Women's Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Insulated Waterproof Jacket vs Marmot Minimalist Pertex 3-in-1 Jacket Women's
  • Mackage 3-in-1 Balmacaan Coat With Removable Down Liner vs Women's 3 in 1 Plus Size Winter Coats Waterproof Ski Jacket Hooded Snowboarding Jacket
  • Patagonia Tres 3-in-1 Parka vs Mackage 3-in-1 Balmacaan Coat With Removable Down Liner

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best women's waterproof winter coats with zip-out liners
  • Best women's waterproof rain jackets with zip-out liners
Everyday
—
Performance StyleOutdoor—
Chest Size50-53.1 (XXL)—
Length23.0 in / 58.4 cm (Center Back Length)—
WidthNo information—
Fastener TypeZipper—
Size (US)2, 30, 10—
Size (Small-Large)3XL, XL, XXL, XS—
Sportswear GarmentYes—
Coats—Down Coat / Padded Coat
Sleeves—Long Sleeve