Which is better for heavy construction work?

The Carhartt Arches. Its 10.6 oz denim is heavier and its 2% elastane plus relaxed hip and thigh cut gives more room to move on a jobsite.

Which has more pockets?

The Dickies 11-Pocket. It lists 11 pockets, including three tool pockets and a hidden zippered back pocket, against the Carhartt's multi-compartment bib, two front, utility and two back pockets.

Which is better if I am short?

The Dickies. It comes in a 29 in short inseam and petite/short sizing; the Carhartt listing gives no inseam or petite option.

Do both take knee pads?

Yes. Both have double-front panels with openings for optional knee pads.

Which fabric lasts longer?

The Carhartt has the heavier denim and a higher cotton share, which usually wears better. The Dickies blend includes viscose, which tends to break down sooner with hard use.

Is one worth paying more for?

No prices were provided for either bib, so check current store prices on this page. If they are close, the Carhartt suits heavy work and the Dickies suits shoppers who need short lengths or more pockets.

Women's Rugged Flex Relaxed Fit Denim Bib Overall - Arches vs Dickies Women's 11-Pocket Double-Front Bib Overall

Both are double-front work bibs with stretch denim and a zippered bib pocket. The Carhartt Arches gives you a heavier 10.6 oz fabric with more elastane (2%) and a relaxed fit through hip and thigh, which suits hard physical work and layering. The Dickies 11-Pocket has more pockets, a hidden zippered back pocket, and comes in short and petite lengths, which suits shorter shoppers and anyone who wants more storage. No current prices were provided for either, so compare live store prices before buying.

Ask our shopping agent