Which is better for hot weather?

The Berne. Its 7.9 oz denim is about a third lighter than Carhartt's 10.6 oz, and buyers say it stays comfortable all day in summer.

The Carhartt. Heavier 10.6 oz denim, double-stitched seams, reinforced back pockets and a double front give it more abrasion resistance. The Berne's light stretch denim is built for comfort first.

Is the Carhartt worth the extra cost?

If you do rough work like painting, plastering or kneeling on job sites, yes. For light chores and casual wear, the lighter Berne does the job and costs less at most stores.

Which fits better over a curvy hip?

The Carhartt is a relaxed fit through hip and thigh with a straight leg. The Berne lists a 22 in hip and a bootcut leg with an adjustable waist, so it suits a closer fit you can tighten.

Do both have a phone-sized bib pocket?

Yes. Both have a zippered bib pocket that fits a phone. The Carhartt adds multiple compartments; the Berne adds a tape measure opening and side utility pockets.

Can I wear knee pads in either?

Only the Carhartt has a double-front design made for knee pads. The Berne has no knee pad layer.

Women's Vintage Washed Flex Denim Bib Overall vs Women's Rugged Flex Relaxed Fit Denim Bib Overall - Arches

Buy the Berne Vintage Washed Flex if you want a light, stretchy bib for summer work and casual wear. Buy the Carhartt Rugged Flex if you need heavier denim that holds up to mud, paint and knee pads. The Berne has only 6 ratings at 5 stars; the Carhartt has 63 at 4.5, so the Carhartt's record is far better tested. No prices were given for either, so compare live store prices before you decide.

Ask our shopping agent