Is the Alfani Andrew worth buying?

At $20.00 at eBay as of November 5, 2026, it is a cheap way to get a presentable work oxford. Expect a short life if you wear it daily; it suits occasional office wear better than all-day use.

How does the Andrew fit compared with other oxfords?

It runs somewhat narrow, and the almond toe leaves little room up front. If you are between sizes or have wide feet, size up or try it on before committing.

No. The upper, lining, insole and outsole are all manmade, with a faux leather lining and insole. That keeps the price down but limits breathability and long-term durability.

Can I wear it with a suit?

Yes. The plain-toe derby shape works with suits and dress pants, though the manmade finish looks less refined than leather up close.

When is the Andrew cheapest?

Prices swing with department-store clearance and resale listings. The lowest new price seen is $20.00 at eBay as of November 5, 2026; check the price history before paying full retail.

Where is the Alfani Andrew cheapest?

At Macy's, for $27.99, 60% off, as of our latest check.

What do buyers say about the Alfani Andrew?

Rated 3.9 out of 5 from 539 ratings. Buyers like: Comfortable; Stylish and suitable for various occasions; Sleek, traditional design with a smooth finish. Common complaints: Quality and durability feedback is mixed; Sizing and fit are inconsistent.

Where can I buy the Alfani Andrew?

6 stores we checked sell it, including eBay, Macy's, Mercari, Poshmark, Walmart.

Alfani Andrew

3.9

Best price now

$27.99at Macy'sObserved at 7:33 AM

Deal: 60% off at Macy's →

Compared across 5 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Macy's

Alfani Andrew

3.9

Best price now

$27.99at Macy'sObserved at 7:33 AM

Deal: 60% off at Macy's →

Compared across 5 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Macy's

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Our take on the Alfani Andrew

The Alfani Andrew is a men's lace-up oxford in manmade materials with a faux leather lining and a memory foam insole. It is a plain-toe derby built for workdays, with hidden eyelets and a small logo accent. The best new price is $20.00 at eBay as of November 5, 2026, well below what most department-store shoppers pay for it.

Best forMen who need a dress-code office shoe on a budgetWearers who stand or walk much of the workdayShoppers who want a derby that pairs with slacks and suitsBuying a backup pair for occasional formal wear

Pros

Memory foam insole adds cushioning for long days
Plain almond toe reads clean and formal
Lace-up derby fit is easy to adjust
Low price at $20.00 at eBay as of November 5, 2026
Manmade upper wipes clean easily

Cons

Manmade upper and lining breathe poorly and can run warm
Faux leather lining may crack or peel with heavy use
Not built to be resoled, so lifespan is limited
Fit and finish vary more than on leather oxfords

Alfani Andrew prices at every store

Macy'sNew
In stock
$27.99Observed at 7:33 AM
Visit store
eBayNew
In stockSold by parsimono
$52.00Observed at 7:33 AM
Visit store
WalmartNew
In stockSold by HFS COMMERCE
$69.99Observed at 4:36 AM
Visit store
MercariNew
Availability unknown
$38.00Observed at 7:33 AM
Visit store
PoshmarkNew
Availability unknown
$52.00Observed at 7:33 AM
Visit store

Also available at

LystCheck price at Lyst
eBayCheck price at eBay

Alfani Andrew price history

Lowest price we've seen: $20.00 on Nov 5 at eBay. Tracked across 6 stores since Nov 5.

What reviewers say

Rated 3.9 out of 5 from 539 ratings, the Andrew draws mixed feedback. Buyers like the look and the cushioning for the price; complaints center on durability and comfort over long wear.

Pros

Looks sharper than its price
Memory foam insole is comfortable at first
Light and easy to break in

Cons

Upper and lining wear out within months of daily wear
Sizing runs narrow or inconsistent
Feet get sweaty in the manmade lining

From Macy's

Plain toe
Lace-up closure with hidden eyelets
Padded collar for comfort
Sleek lace-up oxford style for workday wear
Macy's Exclusive

Sizes: 7, 7.5, 8, 8.5, 9, 9.5, 11, 11.5, 12, 13
Materials: Synthetic upper; man-made sole
Fit: Derby/plain-toe dress shoe with almond/round toe
Sizing: Reviews are mixed: some find them true to size, others say they run narrow or small; one reviewer found them too tight and too long. On average, customers rate
Returns: Returns are accepted at any Macy's store within 30 days from purchase date; Last Act items are final sale and sold "as is" with no returns, exchanges, or price
Shipping: This item qualifies for Free Shipping with minimum purchase (exclusions apply); enter your zip code for shipping availability.

What buyers say

Buyers like

Comfortable
Stylish and suitable for various occasions
Sleek, traditional design with a smooth finish
Looks expensive
Great for long workdays
Pairs well with a dark suit

Buyers complain about

Quality and durability feedback is mixed
Sizing and fit are inconsistent
Some find them narrow or small
One reviewer found them too tight and too long
One customer received the wrong size in the box

Specifications

Gender: Men's
Material: Manmade
Type: Oxford
Closure Style: Lace-up
Occasion: Workday
Outsole Material: Man-made
Sole Material: Man-made
Age Group

Questions and answers

Is the Alfani Andrew worth buying?: At $20.00 at eBay as of November 5, 2026, it is a cheap way to get a presentable work oxford. Expect a short life if you wear it daily; it suits occasional office wear better than all-day use.
How does the Andrew fit compared with other oxfords?: It runs somewhat narrow, and the almond toe leaves little room up front. If you are between sizes or have wide feet, size up or try it on before committing.
Is it real leather?: No. The upper, lining, insole and outsole are all manmade, with a faux leather lining and insole. That keeps the price down but limits breathability and long-term durability.
Can I wear it with a suit?: Yes. The plain-toe derby shape works with suits and dress pants, though the manmade finish looks less refined than leather up close.
When is the Andrew cheapest?: Prices swing with department-store clearance and resale listings. The lowest new price seen is $20.00 at eBay as of November 5, 2026; check the price history before paying full retail.
Where is the Alfani Andrew cheapest?: At Macy's, for $27.99, 60% off, as of our latest check.
What do buyers say about the Alfani Andrew?: Rated 3.9 out of 5 from 539 ratings. Buyers like: Comfortable; Stylish and suitable for various occasions; Sleek, traditional design with a smooth finish. Common complaints: Quality and durability feedback is mixed; Sizing and fit are inconsistent.
Where can I buy the Alfani Andrew?: 6 stores we checked sell it, including eBay, Macy's, Mercari, Poshmark, Walmart.