Black FridayDealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Alfani
Alfani
Alfani Theo Cap Toe Oxford Dress Shoe

Alfani Theo Cap Toe Oxford Dress Shoe

4.4· 175 ratings

Best price now

$27.99at Macy'sObserved at 3:23 AM
Deal: 60% off at Macy's →

Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Macy's

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

Our take on the Alfani Theo Cap Toe Oxford Dress Shoe

The Alfani Theo is a men's cap-toe Oxford in faux leather with a rubber outsole, blind eyelets and a memory foam footbed. It is a Macy's exclusive aimed at dress-casual wear rather than formal suiting. At $27.99 at Macy's as of November 5, 2026, it sits at the low end of its recent range, and only one store currently lists it new.

Best forMen who need a dressy shoe on a tight budgetOffice and business-casual outfitsWeddings and events where the shoe may get scuffedShoppers who want a cushioned footbed for standing
Pros
  • Memory foam footbed adds cushioning underfoot
  • Cap-toe Oxford styling reads dressier than a sneaker
  • Rubber outsole gives decent traction on wet pavement
  • Blind eyelets and contrast outsole add visual interest
  • Low price at $27.99 at Macy's as of November 5, 2026
Cons
  • Upper is faux leather, not real leather, so it creases and ages faster
  • Sole and lining are synthetic, which limits breathability
  • Several buyers say it runs large, so sizing down may be needed
  • Durability and material quality draw mixed reports
  • Only one store lists it new, so price competition is limited

Alfani Theo Cap Toe Oxford Dress Shoe prices at every store

  • Macy'sNew

    In stock

    $27.99Observed at 3:23 AM
    Visit store

Also available at

  • LystCheck price at Lyst

Alfani Theo Cap Toe Oxford Dress Shoe price history

Lowest price we've seen: $27.99 on Nov 5 at Macy's. Tracked across 2 stores since Nov 5.

What reviewers say

Rated 4.4 out of 5 from 175 ratings. Owners mostly call it comfortable for long wear and good value for the money, with fit and material quality the main sticking points.

Pros
  • Comfortable for extended wear
  • Versatile enough for dress and casual outfits
  • Fits true to size for many buyers
  • Holds up to heavy use for the price
Cons
  • Some buyers find it runs large
  • Mixed views on durability and material quality

From Macy's

  • Cap-toe lace-up Oxford dress shoe
  • Blind eyelets with contrast outsole
  • Durable rubber outsole
  • Macy's Exclusive
  • Comfort feature
  • Lace up
Sizes
7, 7.5, 8, 8.5, 9, 9.5, 10, 10.5, 11, 11.5, 12
Materials
Polyurethane/manmade faux leather upper; mesh/polyurethane lining; rubber outsole
Fit
Oxford dress shoe style; round toe
Sizing
Many customers find the shoes fit true to size, though some report them running large; customers on average rate runs narrow/runs wide and runs small/runs large
Returns
Returns are accepted at any Macy's store within 30 days from purchase date; Last Act items are final sale
Shipping
This item qualifies for Free Shipping with minimum purchase

What buyers say

Buyers like
  • Very comfortable for extended wear
  • Stylish and versatile for various occasions
  • Fits true to size for many
  • Durable and holds up to heavy use
  • Good traction
  • Great value
Buyers complain about
  • Some report the shoes run large
  • Mixed opinions on durability and quality of materials

Specifications

Gender
Men's
Type
Oxford
Closure Style
Lace-up
Material
Rubber (outsole)
Leather Material
Faux leather
Occasion
Dress
Outsole Material
Rubber
Sole Material

Questions and answers

Is the Alfani Theo worth buying at $27.99?
At $27.99 at Macy's as of November 5, 2026, it is a low-cost dress shoe with a cushioned footbed. It suits occasional dress wear; if you need a shoe that lasts years, spend more on real leather.
Does the Alfani Theo run true to size?
Many buyers say it fits true to size, but a number report it runs large. If you are between sizes or wear thin dress socks, consider sizing down half a size.
Is the upper real leather?
No. The upper is faux leather, and the lining is polyurethane and mesh. That keeps the price down but means it will crease and wear faster than genuine leather.
Can I wear it for long days on my feet?
The memory foam footbed and rubber outsole make it comfortable for extended wear, according to buyers. The synthetic lining traps heat, so it is less breathable than a leather-lined shoe.
What is in the box?
The shoes come as a pair with laces already fitted through the blind eyelets. No shoe trees, bags or extra laces are included.
When is the best time to buy it?
Macy's-exclusive shoes like this one usually drop during storewide sales and clearance events. The current $27.99 is already near the bottom of its recent range.
Where is the Alfani Theo Cap Toe Oxford Dress Shoe cheapest?
At Macy's, for $27.99, 60% off, as of our latest check.
What do buyers say about the Alfani Theo Cap Toe Oxford Dress Shoe?
Rated 4.4 out of 5 from 175 ratings. Buyers like: Very comfortable for extended wear; Stylish and versatile for various occasions; Fits true to size for many. Common complaints: Some report the shoes run large; Mixed opinions on durability and quality of materials.
Where can I buy the Alfani Theo Cap Toe Oxford Dress Shoe?
2 stores we checked sell it, including Macy's, Lyst.

More from Alfani

  • A
    Alfani Men's Slim-Fit Suit Jacket
    Alfani Men's Slim-Fit Suit Jacket
  • A
    Alfani Men's Slim-Fit Stretch Solid Suit Jacket
    Alfani Men's Slim-Fit Stretch Solid Suit Jacket
  • A
    Alfani Men's Solid Regular-Fit Dress Shirt
    Alfani Men's Solid Regular-Fit Dress Shirt
  • A
    Alfani Slim-Fit Suit Jacket
    Alfani Slim-Fit Suit Jacket
  • A
    Alfani Men's Slim Fit Suit Jacket Blazer
    Alfani Men's Slim Fit Suit Jacket Blazer
  • A
    Alfani Andrew
    Alfani Andrew
  • A
    Alfani Otis Bit Loafers
    Alfani Otis Bit Loafers
  • A
    Alfani Quinn Faux Leather Lace Up Oxfords
    Alfani Quinn Faux Leather Lace Up Oxfords
All Alfani deals and products →
Rubber
Age Group
Adult
Department
Men's
Memory Foam
Yes
Lining Material
Polyurethane, Mesh
Toe Style
Cap toe
Design Style
Casual
Decorative Accents
Blind eyelets
Visual Attributes
Contrast outsole