StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Allen Edmonds
Allen Edmonds
Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Cap-toe Oxford Dress Shoe

Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Cap-toe Oxford Dress Shoe

4.4(1,700 ratings)

Best price now

$49.99at WhatnotChecked Nov 19
Deal: 40% off at Allen Edmonds →

Compared across 17 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

2 cheaper alternatives in the Deal.ai store

Checking the Deal.ai store…

from $43.99
  • M
    Men's Pointed Toe Lace-Up Oxford ShoesFree shippingArrives Nov 28 – Dec 8$44.99Save $5.00
  • M
    Men's Textured Toe Oxford Dress ShoesFree shippingArrives Nov 28 – Dec 8$43.99Save $6.00
See cheaper alternatives

Price facts

  • Last seen at $49.99 at Whatnot on Nov 19.
  • That's the lowest price we've seen since Oct 28.
  • Since Oct 28 it has ranged from $49.99 to $450.00.
  • Checked at 17 stores.
$49.99at WhatnotChecked Nov 19
Visit Whatnot

Our take on the Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Cap-toe Oxford Dress Shoe

The Fifth Avenue is Allen Edmonds' cap-toe balmoral oxford, Goodyear welted and made in Port Washington, Wisconsin. It uses a single-layer vegetable-tanned leather outsole and a CustomCork insole that molds to the foot over time. It comes in narrow, medium and wide widths. It is a recraftable, conservative dress shoe that owners say runs true to size and needs a break-in period.

Best forMen who need a conservative interview or office shoeBuyers who want a recraftable, long-lasting dress shoeWearers with narrow or wide feetSuit-and-tie formal occasions
Pros
  • Goodyear welted, so the sole can be replaced by Allen Edmonds
  • Full leather lining and leather outsole for a formal, low-profile look
  • CustomCork insole breaks in to the shape of your foot
  • Available in narrow, medium and wide widths
  • Cap-toe brogue detailing works for business and formal wear
  • Made in the US at Allen Edmonds' Wisconsin factory
Cons
  • Leather outsole is slick on wet pavement and wears faster than rubber
  • Stiff at first; break-in takes several wears
  • Full retail is high, and the price swings widely
  • Not a shoe for rain, snow or long walking days

Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Cap-toe Oxford Dress Shoe prices at every store

  • Allen EdmondsNew

    In stock

    $249.00+ $10.00 shippingChecked 22 h ago
    Visit Allen Edmonds
  • Allen EdmondsNew

    In stock

    $369.00Free shippingChecked Nov 14
    Visit Allen Edmonds
  • EditorialistNew

    In stock

    $450.00Free shippingChecked 22 h ago
    Visit Editorialist
  • MensDesignerShoe.comNew

    In stock

    $450.00Free shippingChecked 22 h ago
    Visit MensDesignerShoe.com
  • J. Men's ClothingNew

    In stock

    $450.00Free shippingChecked Nov 19
    Visit J. Men's Clothing
  • Sherman Brothers ShoesNew

    In stock

    $450.00Free shippingChecked Nov 19
    Visit Sherman Brothers Shoes
  • Sherman Brothers ShoesNew

    In stock

    $450.00Free shippingChecked Nov 14
    Visit Sherman Brothers Shoes
  • J. Men's ClothingNew

    In stock

    $450.00Free shippingChecked Nov 14
    Visit J. Men's Clothing
  • WhatnotNew

    Availability unknown

    $49.99Checked Nov 19
    Visit Whatnot
  • Books of DiscoveryNew

    Availability unknown

    $119.00Checked Nov 13
    Visit Books of Discovery
  • MercariNew

    Availability unknown

    $160.69Checked Nov 19
    Visit Mercari
  • Sui Generis Designer ConsignmentPre-owned

    Availability unknown

    $202.00Checked Nov 19
    Visit Sui Generis Designer Consignment
  • Sui Generis Designer ConsignmentNew

    Availability unknown

    $202.00Checked Nov 16
    Visit Sui Generis Designer Consignment
  • PoshmarkPre-owned

    Availability unknown

    $228.00Checked Nov 15
    Visit Poshmark
  • PoshmarkNew

    Availability unknown

    $275.00Checked Nov 16
    Visit Poshmark
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $302.99Free shippingChecked 22 h ago
    Visit Amazon
  • Daniels ShoesNew

    Availability unknown

    $395.00Checked Nov 19
    Visit Daniels Shoes
  • O'Connell's ClothingNew

    Availability unknown

    $425.00Checked Nov 13
    Visit O'Connell's Clothing
  • Daphne's Shoe BoutiqueNew

    Availability unknown

    $450.00Checked Nov 16
    Visit Daphne's Shoe Boutique

Store links may earn us a commission.

Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Cap-toe Oxford Dress Shoe price history

$450.00$49.99
Oct 28Nov 21

Lowest price we've seen: $49.99 on Nov 15 at Whatnot; highest $450.00 on Nov 4. Tracked across 17 stores since Oct 28.

What reviewers say

  • 4.4 / 51,700 ratings

Rated 4.4 out of 5 across about 1,700 ratings, with buyers generally reporting it runs true to size. Owners treat it as a durable, recraftable dress shoe that needs a break-in period.

What people mention
  • FitPraisedBuyers report the shoe runs true to size, and multiple widths help.
  • BuildPraisedOwners describe it as sturdy and well made, with Goodyear welting that allows resoling.
  • Break-inMixedComfort improves after several wears, but the first wears are stiff.
  • OutsoleCriticisedThe leather sole is smooth and offers little traction, especially when wet.

From Allen Edmonds

  • Lace-up balmoral dress shoe with brogue detailing
  • 360° Goodyear welt construction for durability and stability
  • Soft leather lining
  • Single layer, vegetable-tanned leather outsoles for a sleek, low profile
  • CustomCork insoles mold to the unique shape of your foot
  • Handcrafted in Port Washington, Wisconsin with imported materials
Sizes
5, 5.5, 6, 6.5, 7, 7.5, 8, 8.5, 9, 9.5, 10, 10.5, 11, 11.5, 12, 12.5, 13, 14, 15, 16
Materials
Ultra-refined, premium European calfskin leather upper; soft leather lining; vegetable-tanned leather outsoles; CustomCork insoles
Fit
Classic, take your regular size
Sizing
Reviews say these are true to size; the page says classic fit, take your regular size. Widths offered: AAAA, AAA, AA, A, B, C, D, E, EE, EEE.
Guarantee
Can be recrafted by Allen Edmonds experts
Returns
Marked FINAL SALE. No Returns
Shipping
Ship to Address: receive in 3-5 business days with standard shipping; Store Pickup is free.

About the Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Cap-toe Oxford Dress Shoe

The Fifth Avenue is a cap-toe oxford dress shoe in a lace-up balmoral style with brogue detailing. The uppers are premium European calfskin leather, and the interior is leather lined. It is built on the brand's 65 footwear last.

It has a 360° Goodyear bench welt construction for durability and stability. The single-layer, vegetable-tanned leather outsole gives it a sleek, low profile. CustomCork insoles mold to the shape of the wearer's foot.

The shoe is handcrafted in Port Washington, Wisconsin, with imported materials. It can be recrafted by the brand's experts. The fit is classic, so wearers take their regular size.

Department
Men's
Upper
European calfskin leather
Lining
Leather
Outsole
Single-layer, vegetable-tanned leather
Insole
CustomCork
Closure
Lace-up (balmoral)
Toe style
Cap toe
Embellishment
Brogue detailing
Style
Formal
Construction
360° Goodyear bench welt
Last
65 footwear last
Fit
Classic; take your regular size
Made in
Port Washington, Wisconsin, with imported materials
Care
Can be recrafted by the brand's experts

What buyers say

Buyers like
  • True to size according to reviews

Specifications

Width
Width Narrow, Width Medium, Width Wide
Department
Men's
Material
Genuine Leather
Closure Style
Lace-up
Style
Formal
Embellishment Style
Brogue
Lining Material
Leather

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

Questions and answers

Is the Fifth Avenue true to size?
Buyers report it runs true to size. If you wear orthotics or thick socks, consider going up half a size or choosing a wider width.
Can the sole be replaced?
Yes. The 360-degree Goodyear welt lets Allen Edmonds recraft the shoe with a new sole rather than replacing it.
How does it compare with the Park Avenue?
Both are cap-toe balmorals on leather soles. The Fifth Avenue has brogue detailing and a slightly less plain look; the Park Avenue is the plainer, more formal option.
What widths are available?
It comes in narrow, medium and wide widths.
Is it good for everyday wear?
It suits office and formal wear. The leather sole and stiff break-in make it a poor choice for rain, snow or long walking days.
Where is the Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Cap-toe Oxford Dress Shoe cheapest?
At Whatnot, for $49.99, 40% off, as of our latest check.
Is the Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Cap-toe Oxford Dress Shoe at its lowest price?
Yes: $49.99 is the lowest price we've seen for it since October 28.
What do buyers say about the Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Cap-toe Oxford Dress Shoe?
Rated 4.4 out of 5 from 1,700 ratings. Buyers like: True to size according to reviews.
Where can I buy the Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Cap-toe Oxford Dress Shoe?
14 stores we checked sell it, including Amazon, Allen Edmonds, Editorialist, MensDesignerShoe.com, Whatnot.

Stores we've priced the Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Cap-toe Oxford Dress Shoe at

  • Allen Edmonds deals and prices
  • Books of Discovery deals and prices
  • Whatnot deals and prices

More from Allen Edmonds

  • A
    Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford
    Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue Oxford
  • A
    Allen Edmonds Tompkins Men's Boot
    Allen Edmonds Tompkins Men's Boot
Outsole Material
Leather Outsole
Toe Style
Cap Toe
  • A
    Allen Edmonds Park Avenue
    Allen Edmonds Park Avenue
  • A
    Allen Edmonds Windsor Plain Toe Derby
    Allen Edmonds Windsor Plain Toe Derby
  • A
    Allen Edmonds Windsor Men's Shoe
    Allen Edmonds Windsor Men's Shoe
  • A
    Allen Edmonds Park Cap Toe Boot
    Allen Edmonds Park Cap Toe Boot
  • A
    Allen Edmonds Windsor Derby Leather
    Allen Edmonds Windsor Derby Leather
  • A
    Allen Edmonds Winston Wingtip Brogue Derby
    Allen Edmonds Winston Wingtip Brogue Derby
  • All Allen Edmonds deals and products →

    More men's oxford dress shoes

    • G
      Gordon Rush Men's Plain Toe Oxford Dress Shoes
      Gordon Rush Men's Plain Toe Oxford Dress Shoes
    • A
      Alfani Theo Cap Toe Oxford Dress Shoe
      Alfani Theo Cap Toe Oxford Dress Shoe