StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Johnston & Murphy › Loafers
Johnston & Murphy
Johnston & Murphy Collier Penny Loafer

Johnston & Murphy Collier Penny Loafer

4.4(7 ratings)

Best price now

$79.97at Nordstrom RackChecked Nov 14
Deal: 60% off at Jos. A. Bank →

Compared across 19 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Finding cheaper alternatives

Checking the Deal.ai store…

Price facts

  • Last seen at $79.97 at Nordstrom Rack on Nov 14.
  • Since Nov 2 it has ranged from $59.99 to $155.00.
  • Checked at 19 stores.
$79.97at Nordstrom RackChecked Nov 14
Visit Nordstrom Rack

Our take on the Johnston & Murphy Collier Penny Loafer

The Collier is Johnston & Murphy's take on the classic handsewn penny loafer, built with a moc toe and penny keeper, a lightweight lug sole and a TRUFOAM footbed with memory foam. It is a dress-casual shoe meant to go from the office to a relaxed weekend. Buyers call it sharp-looking and comfortable, with the navy suede drawing the most praise.

Best forMen who want a dress-casual loafer for everyday wearWearers who stand or walk a lot and want cushioned comfortShoppers dressing up or kicking back in the same shoeBuyers who prefer a removable, molded footbed
Pros
  • Handsewn moc toe with penny keeper gives a classic look
  • TRUFOAM footbed with memory foam adds lasting cushioning
  • Lightweight lug rubber outsole keeps the shoe flexible
  • Removable molded footbed can be swapped or aired out
  • Natural edge finish updates the traditional penny silhouette
  • Leather lining and suede or leather upper
Cons
  • Limited color choices; buyers wanted more shades at the sale price
  • Some buyers questioned whether the shoes were genuine
  • Sizing runs in whole and half sizes only, with no width options listed
  • Limited color choices; buyers wanted more shades
  • Availability is inconsistent, so the model may not stay in stock

Johnston & Murphy Collier Penny Loafer prices at every store

  • Nordstrom RackNew

    In stock

    $79.97Checked Nov 14
    Visit Nordstrom Rack
  • BelkNew

    In stock

    $155.00Free shippingChecked Nov 18
    Visit Belk
  • LystNew

    In stock

    $158.95Checked Nov 11
    Visit Lyst
  • DSWNew

    In stock

    $159.99+ $7.95 shippingChecked 21 h ago
    Visit DSW
  • Johnston & MurphyNew

    In stock

    $159.00+ $9.95 shippingChecked Nov 19
    Visit Johnston & Murphy
  • eBayPre-owned

    Availability unknownReturns: Set by the eBay seller; the eBay Money Back Guarantee covers an item that doesn't arrive or isn't as described.

    $35.00+ $14.20 shippingChecked Nov 9
    Visit eBay
  • eBayNew

    Availability unknownSold by sneakar

    $79.99Checked Nov 19
    Visit eBay
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $139.50Free shippingChecked 21 h ago
    Visit Amazon
  • 6pm.comNew

    Availability unknown

    $139.50Checked Nov 18
    Visit 6pm.com
  • CS MenswearNew

    Availability unknown

    $149.00Free shippingChecked Nov 11
    Visit CS Menswear
  • Sole ProvisionsNew

    Availability unknown

    $154.95Checked Nov 14
    Visit Sole Provisions
  • DSWNew

    Availability unknown

    $154.99Checked Nov 19
    Visit DSW
  • Macy'sNew

    Availability unknown

    $155.00Checked Nov 19
    Visit Macy's
  • NordstromNew

    Availability unknown

    $158.95Checked Nov 19
    Visit Nordstrom
  • Zappos.comNew

    Availability unknown

    $158.95Checked Nov 19
    Visit Zappos.com
  • Tip Top ShoesNew

    Availability unknown

    $158.95Checked Nov 19
    Visit Tip Top Shoes
  • Dillard'sNew

    Availability unknown

    $159.00Checked Nov 19
    Visit Dillard's
  • Lamey WellehanNew

    Availability unknown

    $159.00Checked Nov 18
    Visit Lamey Wellehan
  • Sherman Brothers ShoesNew

    Availability unknown

    $159.00Checked Nov 9
    Visit Sherman Brothers Shoes
  • Jos. A. BankNew

    Availability unknown

    $59.99Checked Nov 2
    Visit Jos. A. Bank

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

Johnston & Murphy Collier Penny Loafer price history

$155.00$59.99
Nov 2Nov 21

Lowest price we've seen: $59.99 on Nov 2 at Jos. A. Bank; highest $155.00 on Nov 4. Tracked across 19 stores since Nov 2.

What reviewers say

Buyers describe the Collier as a sharp-looking, comfortable loafer and good value for Johnston & Murphy. The navy suede in particular draws praise.

What people mention
  • ComfortPraisedBuyers call the TRUFOAM and memory foam footbed comfortable for everyday wear.
  • AppearancePraisedThe navy suede finish is singled out as sharp-looking.
  • ValuePraisedBuyers see the loafer as good value for a Johnston & Murphy shoe.
  • Color rangeCriticisedBuyers wish more colors were offered.
  • AuthenticityCriticisedSome buyers doubted whether the shoes they received were genuine.

From Jos. A. Bank

  • Hand-sewn moc toe with penny keeper
  • Lightweight lug sole
  • TRUFOAM footbed for lasting comfort
  • Flexible rubber outsole with lightweight cushioned comfort
  • Removable, molded footbed with memory foam
  • Online exclusive
Sizes
9 D Width
Materials
Full grain leather; leather and anti-microbial polymesh lining (50% recycled); flexible rubber outsole; removable molded footbed with memory foam
Fit
D width
Sizing
Fit rated 3 out of 5, where 1 equals runs small and 5 equals runs large
Returns
Free returns on every purchase; return within 90 days from original date of purchase at any Jos. A. Bank store or by mail at no cost
Shipping
Item ships direct from vendor via standard shipping only; allow 7 business days for delivery; free standard shipping on online orders over the threshold placed

About the Johnston & Murphy Collier Penny Loafer

The Collier Penny Loafer is a men's slip-on loafer with a hand-sewn moc toe and a penny keeper. It has a lightweight lug sole and a TRUFOAM®-cushioned footbed.

The upper is full grain leather, and the lining is leather and anti-microbial polymesh (50% recycled). The outsole is flexible rubber, and the footbed is removable, molded and has memory foam.

It is an everyday shoe for dressing up or kicking back.

Style
Penny loafer
Toe
Hand-sewn moc toe with penny keeper
Fastening
Slip-on
Upper
Full grain leather
Lining
Leather and anti-microbial polymesh (50% recycled)
Sole
Lightweight lug sole
Outsole
Flexible rubber
Midsole
EVA
Footbed
TRUFOAM®-cushioned, removable, molded, with memory foam
Fit
D width
Use
Everyday wear
Occasion
Dressing up, kicking back
Department
Men's
Age group
Adult
Colors
Blue, Natural

What buyers say

Buyers like
  • Great shoes; wish other colors were available at the sale price
  • Navy suede looks very sharp
  • Good value for Johnston & Murphy loafers
Buyers complain about
  • Clearance order took two weeks and never arrived
  • Doubts about whether the shoes were real

Specifications

Numeric Size
9.5
Fit Width
No information
Gender Size
Men's 11, Men's 11.5, Men's 13
Men'S Size
Size 9.5, Size 10, Size 10.5, Size 11, Size 11.5
Age Group Size
Adult size
Department Size
Men's
Department
Men's
Suitable For Size
Men's Size
Age Group
Adult
Occasion
Dressing up, Kicking back
Running Shoes
No
Weightlifting Shoes
No
Size (US)
11, 12, 8.5, 8, 11.5klarna.com
Fastening
Slip-Onklarna.com
Color
Blue, Naturalklarna.com
Outsole
EVA, Syntheticklarna.com
Lining
Leatherklarna.com
Upper Material
Suede, Leatherklarna.com
Midsole
EVAklarna.com
Insole
Leatherklarna.com

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

Questions and answers

Is the Collier Penny Loafer true to size?
It is listed in men's whole and half sizes from 9.5 to 11.5, with no width options shown. Buyers generally treat it as a standard-fit loafer, so start with your usual dress-shoe size.
How does it compare with other Johnston & Murphy loafers?
The Collier uses a lightweight lug sole and a removable TRUFOAM footbed, which makes it softer and more casual than traditional leather-soled pennies. It is a dress-casual shoe rather than a formal one.
Is the footbed removable?
Yes. The molded footbed has memory foam and can be removed, so you can replace it with your own insole or air it out.
What colors are available?
Navy suede is the color buyers mention most, and shoppers have asked for more shades. Check the current listing for the colors in stock.
Can I wear it with a suit?
It works with dress-casual outfits and separates, but the lug sole and natural edge finish make it less formal than a leather-soled penny loafer. For a suit, a sleeker shoe is a safer pick.
What is the sole made of?
A flexible rubber outsole with a lightweight lug pattern, cushioned for comfort. It grips better than a smooth leather sole but looks more casual.
What is the upper made of?
The upper comes in suede or leather, with a leather lining. The natural edge finish is what gives the shoe its updated, less polished look.
Where is the Johnston & Murphy Collier Penny Loafer cheapest?
At Nordstrom Rack, for $79.97, 60% off, as of our latest check.
Is the Johnston & Murphy Collier Penny Loafer at its lowest price?
The lowest price we've seen is $59.99 at Jos. A. Bank on November 2, against $79.97 now.
What do buyers say about the Johnston & Murphy Collier Penny Loafer?
Rated 4.4 out of 5 from 7 ratings. Buyers like: Great shoes; wish other colors were available at the sale price; Navy suede looks very sharp; Good value for Johnston & Murphy loafers. Common complaints: Clearance order took two weeks and never arrived; Doubts about whether the shoes were real.
Where can I buy the Johnston & Murphy Collier Penny Loafer?
17 stores we checked sell it, including DSW, Amazon, Nordstrom, Zappos.com, Johnston & Murphy.

Stores we've priced the Johnston & Murphy Collier Penny Loafer at

  • 6pm.com deals and prices
  • Belk deals and prices
  • Dillard's deals and prices
  • Jos. A. Bank deals and prices
  • Lamey Wellehan deals and prices
  • Lyst deals and prices
  • Macy's deals and prices
  • Nordstrom Rack deals and prices
  • nordstrom.com deals and prices
  • Zappos.com deals and prices

More from Johnston & Murphy

  • J
    Johnston & Murphy Men's XC4 Performance Vest
    Johnston & Murphy Men's XC4 Performance Vest
  • J
    Johnston & Murphy Upton City Coat Men's Coat
    Johnston & Murphy Upton City Coat Men's Coat
  • J
    Johnston & Murphy Ulyssa Wingtip
    Johnston & Murphy Ulyssa Wingtip
  • J
    Johnston & Murphy XC4 Performance Reversible Quarter Zip
    Johnston & Murphy XC4 Performance Reversible Quarter Zip
  • J
    Johnston & Murphy Men's Croc-Embossed Weekender Card Wallet
    Johnston & Murphy Men's Croc-Embossed Weekender Card Wallet
  • J
    Johnston & Murphy Men's Croc-Embossed Leather Billfold Wallet
    Johnston & Murphy Men's Croc-Embossed Leather Billfold Wallet
  • J
    Johnston & Murphy Tristen Western Bootie
    Johnston & Murphy Tristen Western Bootie
  • J
    Johnston & Murphy Men's Upton One-Piece Perfed Plain Toe
    Johnston & Murphy Men's Upton One-Piece Perfed Plain Toe
All Johnston & Murphy deals and products →

More men's loafers

  • A
    Alden Leisure Handsewn Loafer
    Alden Leisure Handsewn Loafer
  • M
    Meermin Penny Loafer
    Meermin Penny Loafer
  • G
    G.H. Bass Larson Weejuns Penny Loafers
    G.H. Bass Larson Weejuns Penny Loafers
  • R
    Ruben Collection - Forest Green Leather Plain Toe Shoes
    Ruben Collection - Forest Green Leather Plain Toe Shoes
  • P
    Premium Emerald Green Velvet Loafers with Patent Leather Accents Formal Event Gentleman's Shoes
    Premium Emerald Green Velvet Loafers with Patent Leather Accents Formal Event Gentleman's Shoes
  • D
    Ducapo Emerald Green Texture Bit Loafers
    Ducapo Emerald Green Texture Bit Loafers
  • T
    The Emerald Croco Tassel Loafers
    The Emerald Croco Tassel Loafers
  • B
    BOSPHORUS LEATHER LOAFER - WOVEN EMERALD
    BOSPHORUS LEATHER LOAFER - WOVEN EMERALD