47% under what the other stores charge
Compared across 7 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.
The Gibbons is a waterproof leather cap-toe oxford from Johnston & Murphy, built for men who need a dress shoe that survives wet commutes and slush. The leather upper sits on a rubber and synthetic outsole with a low heel, and the insole layers leather, foam and polyurethane for cushioning underfoot. It comes in normal and wide widths, which helps men who find slim dress lasts too tight. Against classic calf oxfords it trades some polish for weatherproofing; the mixed 3.1 rating suggests buyers like the look and waterproofing but many find the fit or comfort inconsistent.
In stock
In stock
In stock
In stock
In stock
In stock
In stock
Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.
Lowest price we've seen: $68.99 on Nov 20 at Zulily.com. Tracked across 7 stores since Nov 20.
Ratings are lukewarm overall. Buyers tend to like the waterproof build and the dressy cap-toe look, while complaints center on fit, stiffness and comfort over long days.
The Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Cap Toe is a men's Oxford with a cap toe. The upper is leather, and the shoe is waterproof.
The lining is leather and textile, and the insole combines leather, foam, polyurethane, and synthetic materials. The outsole is rubber and synthetic. The shoe has a lace-up front and a low heel.
It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

