StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Johnston & Murphy › Oxford
Johnston & Murphy
Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Cap Toe Shoes

Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Cap Toe Shoes

3.1(93 ratings)

Best price now

$68.99at Zulily.comChecked 1 h ago

47% under what the other stores charge

Compared across 7 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Finding cheaper alternatives

Checking the Deal.ai store…

Price facts

  • Lowest price today: $68.99 at Zulily.com (checked Nov 20, 2026).
  • Checked at 7 stores.
$68.99at Zulily.comChecked 1 h ago
Visit Zulily.com

Our take on the Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Cap Toe Shoes

The Gibbons is a waterproof leather cap-toe oxford from Johnston & Murphy, built for men who need a dress shoe that survives wet commutes and slush. The leather upper sits on a rubber and synthetic outsole with a low heel, and the insole layers leather, foam and polyurethane for cushioning underfoot. It comes in normal and wide widths, which helps men who find slim dress lasts too tight. Against classic calf oxfords it trades some polish for weatherproofing; the mixed 3.1 rating suggests buyers like the look and waterproofing but many find the fit or comfort inconsistent.

Best forMen who commute on foot in rain or snowBusiness casual and office wearWide-footed buyers needing a dress shoeAnyone replacing a leather sole oxford for winter
Pros
  • Waterproof leather upper handles wet weather
  • Cap-toe styling works with suits and chinos
  • Rubber outsole grips better than leather soles
  • Available in wide widths
  • Cushioned foam and polyurethane insole
Cons
  • Mixed reception on fit and comfort
  • Waterproof lining can feel warm and stiff
  • Not a sleek, formal dress shoe silhouette
  • Break-in period reported by some owners

Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Cap Toe Shoes prices at every store

  • Zulily.comNew

    In stock

    $68.99Checked 1 h ago
    Visit Zulily.com
  • ZapposNew

    In stock

    $97.30Free shippingChecked 1 h ago
    Visit Zappos
  • NordstromNew

    In stock

    $129.90Free shippingChecked 1 h ago
    Visit Nordstrom
  • BelkNew

    In stock

    $129.95Free shippingChecked 1 h ago
    Visit Belk
  • Shop SimonNew

    In stock

    $129.90+ $4.95 shippingChecked 1 h ago
    Visit Shop Simon
  • ShoebaccaNew

    In stock

    $138.95Free shippingChecked 1 h ago
    Visit Shoebacca
  • DSWNew

    In stock

    $139.99+ $7.95 shippingChecked 1 h ago
    Visit DSW

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Cap Toe Shoes price history

Lowest price we've seen: $68.99 on Nov 20 at Zulily.com. Tracked across 7 stores since Nov 20.

What reviewers say

  • 3.1 / 593 ratings

Ratings are lukewarm overall. Buyers tend to like the waterproof build and the dressy cap-toe look, while complaints center on fit, stiffness and comfort over long days.

What people mention
  • WaterproofingPraisedOwners say the shoe keeps feet dry in wet weather, which is the main reason they bought it.
  • FitCriticisedSeveral buyers report sizing that runs off, with some needing to size up or exchange.
  • ComfortMixedThe cushioned insole helps, but some find the shoe stiff and tiring over a full day.
  • BuildMixedThe leather and rubber sole feel solid, though a few question long-term durability.
  • StylePraisedReviewers like the cap-toe look, calling it dressy enough for suits and offices.

About the Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Cap Toe Shoes

The Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Cap Toe is a men's Oxford with a cap toe. The upper is leather, and the shoe is waterproof.

The lining is leather and textile, and the insole combines leather, foam, polyurethane, and synthetic materials. The outsole is rubber and synthetic. The shoe has a lace-up front and a low heel.

Brand
Johnston & Murphy
Type
Oxford
Toe
Cap toe
Upper
Leather
Lining
Leather and textile
Insole
Leather, foam, polyurethane, and synthetic
Outsole
Rubber and synthetic
Fastening
Laced
Heel
Low heel
Waterproof
Yes
Gender
Men's
Age group
Adult

Specifications

Fastening
Lacedklarna.com
Heel Type
Low Heelklarna.com
Color
Blackklarna.com
Outsole
Rubber, Syntheticklarna.com
Age Group
Adultklarna.com
Lining
Leather, Textileklarna.com

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

Questions and answers

Is the Gibbons actually waterproof?
Yes. Johnston & Murphy lists it as waterproof, with a leather upper and sealed construction meant to keep water out. It is not a rubber boot, so deep puddles can still get in over the top.
How does it fit compared with other dress shoes?
Fit reports are mixed. It comes in normal and wide widths, so try your usual size first and consider the wide if you have a broader foot.
Can I wear it with a suit?
Yes. The cap toe and low heel read as business dress. The rubber outsole makes it slightly less formal than a leather-soled oxford, so it suits business and business casual best.
Does it need breaking in?
Some owners report stiffness at first, especially around the waterproof lining. Expect a short break-in period before it softens.
What is the outsole made of?
A rubber and synthetic outsole with a low heel. It grips better on wet pavement than a leather sole.
Is it good for winter?
It handles rain, slush and cold pavement better than a standard leather oxford. For heavy snow or long outdoor exposure, a dedicated winter boot is still the better choice.
Where is the Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Cap Toe Shoes cheapest?
At Zulily.com, for $68.99, 47% under what the other stores charge, as of our latest check.
What do buyers say about the Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Cap Toe Shoes?
Rated 3.1 out of 5 from 93 ratings.
Where can I buy the Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Cap Toe Shoes?
7 stores we checked sell it, including Zappos, Shop Simon, Nordstrom, Belk, Shoebacca.

Stores we've priced the Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Cap Toe Shoes at

  • Belk deals and prices
  • nordstrom.com deals and prices
  • Zappos.com deals and prices
  • Zulily.com deals and prices

More from Johnston & Murphy

  • J
    Johnston & Murphy Collier Penny Loafer
Gender
Maleklarna.com
Upper Material
Leatherklarna.com
Width
Normal, Wideklarna.com
Insole
Leather, Foam, Polyurethane, Syntheticklarna.com
Johnston & Murphy Collier Penny Loafer
  • J
    Johnston & Murphy Men's XC4 Performance Vest
    Johnston & Murphy Men's XC4 Performance Vest
  • J
    Johnston & Murphy Upton City Coat Men's Coat
    Johnston & Murphy Upton City Coat Men's Coat
  • J
    Johnston & Murphy Ulyssa Wingtip
    Johnston & Murphy Ulyssa Wingtip
  • J
    Johnston & Murphy XC4 Performance Reversible Quarter Zip
    Johnston & Murphy XC4 Performance Reversible Quarter Zip
  • J
    Johnston & Murphy Men's Croc-Embossed Weekender Card Wallet
    Johnston & Murphy Men's Croc-Embossed Weekender Card Wallet
  • J
    Johnston & Murphy Men's Croc-Embossed Leather Billfold Wallet
    Johnston & Murphy Men's Croc-Embossed Leather Billfold Wallet
  • J
    Johnston & Murphy Tristen Western Bootie
    Johnston & Murphy Tristen Western Bootie
  • All Johnston & Murphy deals and products →

    More men's oxfords

    • D
      Dr. Scholl's Men's Sync Oxford
      Dr. Scholl's Men's Sync Oxford
    • S
      Stacy Adams Men's Shoes Tedesco Cap Toe Oxford
      Stacy Adams Men's Shoes Tedesco Cap Toe Oxford
    • F
      Florsheim Men's Highpoint Plain Toe Oxfords
      Florsheim Men's Highpoint Plain Toe Oxfords
    • D
      Dockers Men's Cooper
      Dockers Men's Cooper
    • C
      Clarks Men's Un.Kenneth
      Clarks Men's Un.Kenneth
    • G
      Gucci Interlocking G Leather Oxford
      Gucci Interlocking G Leather Oxford
    • B
      Belvedere Men's Duke Leather Cap Toe Oxford Men’s Lace-Up Dress Shoes
      Belvedere Men's Duke Leather Cap Toe Oxford Men’s Lace-Up Dress Shoes
    • F
      Florsheim Men's Frenzi Wingtip Oxford
      Florsheim Men's Frenzi Wingtip Oxford