Is the Shiloh II good for snowy winters?

It handles cold, dry days and light damp well, but it is a town boot, not a snow boot. For deep snow or long slushy walks, a taller insulated Merrell snow boot is the better pick.

How does it compare with Merrell's snow boots?

The Shiloh II is lighter and more casual, with leather and felt styling for everyday wear. Merrell's snow boots add more insulation, taller shafts and more aggressive tread for real winter conditions.

Is the footbed removable?

The boot comes with a cushioned footbed for comfort. Merrell does not advertise it as a replaceable orthotic bed, so plan on the stock cushioning unless you size up for an insert.

How does the Shiloh II fit?

It is a standard women's boot fit with a cushioned footbed. Try your usual size first, and size up if you wear thick winter socks.

Can I wear these in rain?

Light rain is fine, but the felt panels absorb water more than leather. Treat the leather and avoid puddles and heavy rain for best results.

What is the Shiloh II best for?

Cold-weather errands, commuting and everyday town wear. It suits shoppers who want a leather-looking boot with a supportive footbed and real outsole grip.

Where is the Merrell Shiloh II Boots cheapest?

At eBay, for $69.99, as of our latest check.

Where can I buy the Merrell Shiloh II Boots?

2 stores we checked sell it, including Walmart, eBay.

Merrell Shiloh II Boots

Best price now

$69.99at eBayChecked Nov 12

Compared across 2 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit eBay

Merrell Shiloh II Boots

Best price now

$69.99at eBayChecked Nov 12

Compared across 2 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit eBay

Merrell discount code →

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Price facts

Last seen at $69.99 at eBay on Nov 12.
Checked at 2 stores.

Our take on the Merrell Shiloh II Boots

The Merrell Shiloh II is a women's casual winter boot built from full-grain leather and felt, aimed at town wear rather than trail use. A cushioned footbed and a shock-absorbing, grippy outsole are the main comfort features. It sits between fashion dress boots and technical winter boots: warmer and more weather-ready than a plain leather boot, but less insulated and less aggressive underfoot than Merrell's snow boots. Owners of Merrell footwear generally praise the fit and outsole grip, though the felt panels draw more care concerns than all-leather uppers.

Best forCold-weather errands and commuting on footEveryday town wear in fall and winterShoppers who want leather looks with a real outsoleWomen who prefer a cushioned, supportive footbed

Pros

Full-grain leather upper with felt panels for warmth
Cushioned footbed for all-day standing and walking
Shock-absorbing outsole with reliable traction
Merrell's reputation for supportive, well-built footwear
Casual styling that works with jeans and everyday outfits

Cons

Felt panels are harder to clean and less water-resistant than leather
Not a deep-snow or heavy-slush boot
Limited color choice
Break-in may be needed before long walks feel comfortable

Merrell Shiloh II Boots prices at every store

eBayNew
In stockSold by ml4241
$69.99Free shippingChecked Nov 12
Visit eBay
WalmartNew
Out of stockSold by SolemageddonReturns: Sold by a Walmart Marketplace seller; returns go to the seller under the seller's returns policy.
$90.00Checked Nov 12
Visit Walmart

Merrell Shiloh II Boots price history

Lowest price we've seen: $69.99 on Nov 13 at eBay. Tracked across 1 store since Nov 13.

What reviewers say

Feedback on the Shiloh line is generally positive on comfort and grip, with the cushioned footbed and outsole called out most often. The recurring complaints concern the felt upper, which some owners find harder to keep clean and less protective in wet weather.

What people mention

ComfortPraisedOwners say the cushioned footbed stays comfortable through a day of walking.
TractionPraisedThe shock-absorbing outsole is described as grippy on cold, slick surfaces.
Felt upperCriticisedReviewers note the felt panels pick up dirt and are harder to clean than leather.
Weather protectionMixedFine for dry cold and light damp, but owners say it is not a slush or deep-snow boot.
Break-inMixedSome owners report the boots feel stiff for the first few wears before softening.

About the Merrell Shiloh II Boots

The Merrell Shiloh II is a warm women's boot made with full-grain leather and felt. It has a cushioned footbed for comfort.

The outsole is grippy and absorbs shock. The boots are designed for chilly outings around town.

Brand: Merrell
Material: Full-grain leather and felt
Footbed: Cushioned
Outsole: Grippy, shock-absorbing
Color: Brown
Size: 7.5

Specifications

shoe_size: 7.5Source
color: BrownSource
size: 7.5Source

Questions and answers

Is the Shiloh II good for snowy winters?: It handles cold, dry days and light damp well, but it is a town boot, not a snow boot. For deep snow or long slushy walks, a taller insulated Merrell snow boot is the better pick.
How does it compare with Merrell's snow boots?: The Shiloh II is lighter and more casual, with leather and felt styling for everyday wear. Merrell's snow boots add more insulation, taller shafts and more aggressive tread for real winter conditions.
Is the footbed removable?: The boot comes with a cushioned footbed for comfort. Merrell does not advertise it as a replaceable orthotic bed, so plan on the stock cushioning unless you size up for an insert.
How does the Shiloh II fit?: It is a standard women's boot fit with a cushioned footbed. Try your usual size first, and size up if you wear thick winter socks.
Can I wear these in rain?: Light rain is fine, but the felt panels absorb water more than leather. Treat the leather and avoid puddles and heavy rain for best results.
What is the Shiloh II best for?: Cold-weather errands, commuting and everyday town wear. It suits shoppers who want a leather-looking boot with a supportive footbed and real outsole grip.
Where is the Merrell Shiloh II Boots cheapest?: At eBay, for $69.99, as of our latest check.
Where can I buy the Merrell Shiloh II Boots?: 2 stores we checked sell it, including Walmart, eBay.