Is the Holly loafer comfortable for all-day wear?

It has a fabric-lined memory foam insole and a shock-absorbing TPR outsole, which are built for cushioning through the day. The 1 3/4-inch block heel is lower and more stable than a stiletto, so long stretches on your feet are manageable.

Can I wear these in rain or wet weather?

No. The shoe is not water resistant, and the synthetic upper and fabric lining will soak through. Keep them for dry days.

How does the Holly compare with a flat penny loafer?

The Holly adds a 1 3/4-inch block heel and a thicker textured sole, so it looks dressier and gives more lift than a flat. The trade-off is a bit more weight and a less grounded feel.

What is the upper made of?

A synthetic upper with a fabric lining. It wipes clean easily but will not develop the patina or creasing of leather.

One pair of Holly penny loafers. No extra laces or inserts are included.

Do they run true to size?

The listing does not state sizing guidance beyond the standard size run, so try your usual loafer size first.

Where is the Women's Holly Penny Loafer cheapest?

At Eastland, for $70.00, as of our latest check.

Eastland

Women's Holly Penny Loafer

Best price now

$70.00at EastlandChecked Nov 14

Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Eastland

Eastland

Women's Holly Penny Loafer

Best price now

$70.00at EastlandChecked Nov 14

Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Eastland

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Price facts

Last seen at $70.00 at Eastland on Nov 14.

Our take on the Women's Holly Penny Loafer

The Eastland Holly is a women's penny loafer with a synthetic upper, fabric lining and a memory foam insole, set on a 1 3/4-inch block heel and a textured TPR outsole. It leans on the classic penny-loafer look with a lifted sole, so it reads dressier than a flat loafer while staying easy to pull on. The memory foam insole and shock-absorbing outsole target all-day comfort, which is where it competes with leather loafers that cost more but break in harder. It is not water resistant, so it suits dry days and indoor-to-office wear rather than wet commutes.

Best forOffice and business-casual outfitsShoppers who want a heeled loafer without a steep heelAll-day standing and walking on dry surfacesAnyone who prefers pull-on shoes over laces

Pros

Memory foam insole conforms to the foot
Textured TPR outsole adds slip resistance and shock absorption
Modest 1 3/4-inch block heel is stable and walkable
Pull-on penny loafer style slips on quickly
Synthetic upper is easy to wipe clean

Cons

Not water resistant
Synthetic upper will not age or crease like leather
No half sizes or width options noted beyond standard fit
Block heel and thicker sole add weight versus a flat loafer

Women's Holly Penny Loafer prices at every store

EastlandNew
In stockReturn policy
$70.00Checked Nov 14
Visit Eastland

About the Women's Holly Penny Loafer

The Holly is a classic penny loafer with an elevated sole. It has a synthetic upper with a fabric lining and a pull-on closure. The block heel is 1 3/4 inches high.

The fabric-lined memory foam insole conforms to the curves of the foot for support. The textured TPR outsole is slip-resistant and durable, and it cushions against shock. The shoe is not water resistant.

Upper: Synthetic with fabric lining
Insole: Fabric-lined memory foam comfort insole
Outsole: Textured TPR (thermoplastic elastomer)
Sole material: Rubber
Heel height: 1 3/4"
Heel type: Block heel
Closure: Pull-on
Water resistance: Not water resistant
Weight: 454 g

Specifications

Upper material: Synthetic upper with fabric liningSource
Insole: Fabric-lined memory foam comfort insoleSource
Outsole: Textured TPR outsoleSource
Heel height: 1 3/4"Source
Closure type: Pull-OnSource
Heel type: Block HeelSource
Water resistance: Not Water ResistantSource
Sole material: RubberSource
Item weight: 454 gSource
Material type: Thermoplastic ElastomersSource

Questions and answers

Is the Holly loafer comfortable for all-day wear?: It has a fabric-lined memory foam insole and a shock-absorbing TPR outsole, which are built for cushioning through the day. The 1 3/4-inch block heel is lower and more stable than a stiletto, so long stretches on your feet are manageable.
Can I wear these in rain or wet weather?: No. The shoe is not water resistant, and the synthetic upper and fabric lining will soak through. Keep them for dry days.
How does the Holly compare with a flat penny loafer?: The Holly adds a 1 3/4-inch block heel and a thicker textured sole, so it looks dressier and gives more lift than a flat. The trade-off is a bit more weight and a less grounded feel.
What is the upper made of?: A synthetic upper with a fabric lining. It wipes clean easily but will not develop the patina or creasing of leather.
What is in the box?: One pair of Holly penny loafers. No extra laces or inserts are included.
Do they run true to size?: The listing does not state sizing guidance beyond the standard size run, so try your usual loafer size first.
Where is the Women's Holly Penny Loafer cheapest?: At Eastland, for $70.00, as of our latest check.