Best plush pillows for sleeping

Top pick: Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Cloud Pillow — it's rated extra soft, so you get that plush, sink-in feel while still being shaped for back and stomach sleepers. It's the one I'd start with if "soft but supportive" is the goal.

Who the others suit:

• Brooklinen Down Pillow — for anyone who wants a classic feather-and-down loft; it's medium, so softer than a firm pillow but not mushy.
• Casper Original Pillow — a good middle ground for combination sleepers who want plush without a down fill.
• Utopia Bedding 4-pack — the practical choice if you're outfitting a whole bed or guest room in one go.
• SORMAG 2-pack — a hotel-style down-alternative option for people who want fluffy without feathers.

If you sleep hot, look at the Purple Harmony instead — plush feel with better airflow.