Miss Rose 58-Color Makeup Kit vs SHANY All In One Flowers Makeup Set

The SHANY All In One FLOWERS set is the better pick for anyone who wants a wide shade range and a large working surface, with 110 shades against 58 and a palette that opens to 15 by 8 inches. The Miss Rose kit is the more compact, travel-friendly option and bundles brushes, pencils and a mirror, so it works as a starter kit in one box. Owners rate both well, though SHANY's 4.6 from 300 ratings edges Miss Rose's 4.3 from 1,462. Build on both is basic plastic with pressed powder, so expect some fallout and a few chalky shades in each.

• Choose the Miss Rose 58-color kit if you want a self-contained set with brushes, liners and a mirror that packs into a bag for travel or gigs.
• Choose the SHANY Flowers set if you want the widest shade range and a big open palette for blending at a desk or vanity.