Angel Soft 2-Ply Toilet Paper Mega Rolls vs Charmin Essentials Toilet Paper Mega Rolls

Buy Angel Soft if you want a soft, quiet 2-ply roll and a big multi-roll pack that lasts a long time between restocks. Buy Charmin Essentials if wet strength matters most to you: it is engineered to hold together when wet and is approved by Roto-Rooter plumbers. Both are septic safe and both rate 4.7, but Angel Soft's rating comes from a far larger pool of owners, while Charmin Essentials has a much smaller review base.

• Choose the Angel Soft if you want a soft 2-ply sheet, a fragrance-free roll with no inks or dyes, and a large pack that keeps the bathroom stocked.
• Choose the Charmin Essentials if you want a sheet that resists tearing when wet and a roll that is clog-safe and plumber-approved.