Angel Soft 2-Ply Toilet Paper Mega Rolls vs Quilted Northern Ultra Soft & Strong

Buy Angel Soft if you want the simplest, most predictable 2-ply: soft, unscented, septic safe, and backed by a huge base of 4.7-star ratings from over 500,000 shoppers. Buy Quilted Northern Ultra Soft & Strong if you want a thicker, quilted sheet that holds together when wet and needs less paper per use. Reviewers of both call them soft and strong; Quilted Northern owners specifically praise wet strength and fewer wipes, while some complain its rolls have gotten narrower. Angel Soft wins on track record and simplicity; Quilted Northern wins on sheet feel and durability.

• Choose the Angel Soft if you want soft, unscented 2-ply with a long, well-reviewed track record and no fuss.
• Choose the Quilted Northern Ultra Soft & Strong if you want a thicker quilted sheet that resists tearing when wet and goes further per use.