Charmin Essentials Toilet Paper Mega Rolls vs Charmin Ultra Soft Forever Roll

Buy the Ultra Soft Forever Roll if comfort and fewer roll changes matter most: it is 2-ply, 1,700 sheets per roll, and rated slightly higher by owners. Buy Essentials if you want a standard-size roll that fits a normal holder and holds up when wet. Reviewers praise Ultra Soft for softness and longevity; Essentials draws mixed notes on its thin 1-ply feel despite good strength.

• Choose the Charmin Essentials if you want a conventional 12-roll pack that fits any standard holder and resists tearing when wet.
• Choose the Charmin Ultra Soft Forever Roll if you want 2-ply softness and roughly a month between roll changes in a two-person home.