Which is better for a low-flow or septic toilet?

Scott 1000. It is 1-ply, uses clog-free technology, and the brand says it dissolves 10x faster than a soft & strong mega roll. Quilted Northern is also septic safe, but its 2-ply sheets are thicker.

Scott 1000. One pack has 36,000 sheets versus 7,808 for the Quilted Northern pack, so Scott needs far fewer roll changes.

Is Quilted Northern worth the extra money?

If softness matters, yes. It is 2-ply and quilted, and reviewers say it does not tear easily. On cost per sheet the two are close: about 0.18 cents for Scott versus 0.16 cents for Quilted Northern at the November 8, 2026 prices.

Quilted Northern Ultra Soft & Strong. It is 2-ply with a quilted texture, while Scott 1000 is a smooth 1-ply.

Which has a better rating?

Scott 1000 scores 4.6 out of 5 from 134,092 ratings. Quilted Northern scores 4.5 out of 5 from about 20,000 ratings.

How do the pack prices compare?

Scott 1000's 36-roll pack was $6.49 at shopthepapa.com as of November 8, 2026. Quilted Northern's 12 Mega roll pack was $12.78 at eBay the same day, with a recent low of $11.99.

Scott 1000 Toilet Paper vs Quilted Northern Ultra Soft & Strong

Buy Scott 1000 if you want the lowest cost per sheet and a clog-free 1-ply for low-flow toilets. Buy Quilted Northern Ultra Soft & Strong if comfort matters more and you will pay for 2-ply softness. On November 8, 2026, Scott 1000's 36-roll pack was $6.49 at shopthepapa.com, while Quilted Northern's 12 Mega roll pack was $12.78 at eBay. That is roughly 0.18 cents per sheet for Scott versus about 0.16 cents per sheet for Quilted Northern, so the two are close on cost per sheet despite the very different pack prices.

Today the Scott 1000 Toilet Paper costs $6.29 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.