Avenue Butter Denim Pull-On Jean vs BloomChic Stretch Pull-On Jeans

The Avenue Butter Denim is the better pick if you want a true high rise and a choice of petite, average or tall lengths. Its 12-inch rise and wide elastic waistband suit plus-size shoppers who want coverage and a soft pull-on fit. The BloomChic pair sits lower at a 9.5-inch mid rise and comes in one 29-inch inseam, so it fits fewer body types. Avenue owners rate it 3.9 out of 5 and warn it runs small, so size up. BloomChic's higher cotton content feels more like real denim, but it has less stretch and no length options.

• Choose the Avenue Butter Denim if you want a high waist, a wide comfort waistband and petite or tall inseams.
• Choose the BloomChic Stretch Pull-On if you prefer a mid rise and a cotton-rich fabric that feels more like traditional denim.