Which is better for a pull-on jean?

Both are pull-on. The Avenue has a wider comfort waistband and a 12-inch rise; the Torrid has a gap-proof elastic waistband with five-pocket styling. Pick Avenue for a softer, higher waistband.

The Torrid. It is $19.00 at Poshmark as of November 4, 2026, against $42.99 at Target for the Avenue.

Which has more stretch?

The Torrid lists maximum stretch. The Avenue uses butter denim stretch with 2% elastane. Both have 2% stretch fiber, but Torrid rates its fabric at the top of its stretch scale.

Which fits taller shoppers?

Both offer a 33-inch tall inseam. The Torrid also has 31-inch and 25-inch options; the Avenue offers 26-inch petite, 29-inch average and 33-inch tall.

Is the Avenue worth the extra money?

Only if you want the wide comfort waistband and 12-inch rise. Otherwise the Torrid gives similar stretch and more inseam choices for less than half the price.

Does the Avenue run true to size?

No. Avenue says the jeans run small and recommends sizing up for the best fit.

Torrid High-Rise Bombshell Skinny Jeans - Short Inseam vs Avenue Women's Plus Size Petite Butter Denim Pull-On High Rise Jean

Buy the Torrid Bombshell if you want maximum stretch, a true five-pocket skinny, and the lowest price: $19.00 at Poshmark as of November 4, 2026, versus $42.99 at Target for the Avenue pair. Buy the Avenue Butter Denim if you prefer a pull-on jean with a wide elastic waistband and a 12-inch high rise. The Torrid costs less than half as much, but its short inseam is 27 inches, so check length before you commit.

Today the Torrid High-Rise Bombshell Skinny Jeans - Short Inseam costs $23.99 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.