Avenue Butter Denim Pull-On Jean vs Woman Within Plus Size Petite Fineline Stretch Denim Pull-On Bootcut Jeans

The Woman Within Fineline is the safer pick for most shoppers: a 4.0 rating from over 4,700 owners against 3.9 from 100, a bootcut that fits over boots, and a covered elastic waistband. The Avenue Butter Denim is the better choice if you want a skinny leg, a high 12-inch rise, or a tall 33-inch inseam. Both are pull-on stretch denim with no fly; the Avenue runs small, so size up.

• Choose the Avenue Butter Denim if you want a high-rise skinny jean with a wide comfort waistband and a tall inseam option.
• Choose the Woman Within Fineline if you want a bootcut pull-on with a long track record and a covered elastic waist.