Barbour Mooreland Plaid Shirt vs Free People Ashley Plaid Shirt

The Free People Ashley is the heavier, roomier shirt jacket: thick cotton flannel, drop shoulders and a boxy cut that layers over a tee or hoodie. The Barbour Mooreland is the tidier shirt: 100% cotton in a loose but structured oxford-style cut with pleat detail and a classic collar. Owners of the Ashley praise the cozy flannel weight and oversized fit, though some find it too big and boxy for tucking in. The Barbour reads smarter and works better on its own; the Free People works better as an outer layer.

• Choose the Barbour Mooreland if you want a neat, structured plaid shirt you can wear to the office or under a jacket.
• Choose the Free People Ashley if you want a thick flannel overshirt to throw over layers on cold days.