Barbour Mooreland Plaid Shirt vs Style & Co Plaid Cotton Gauze Shirt

The Barbour Mooreland is the better-made shirt: 100% cotton in a loose oxford cut with pleat detailing, from a British brand known for durable country clothing. The Style & Co shirt is a lighter cotton gauze button-up in a regular cut, and it is the easier one to wear casually in warm weather. Buy the Barbour if you want a shirt that holds its shape over years; buy the Style & Co if you want a soft, breezy plaid for everyday wear.

• Choose the Barbour Mooreland if you want a substantial 100% cotton oxford shirt with a loose fit and a brand with a long reputation for hard-wearing outerwear and shirting.
• Choose the Style & Co shirt if you want a soft cotton gauze plaid that feels light and breathable and suits casual, warm-weather wear.