Which is warmer, the Big Chill puffer or the Patagonia Down Sweater Hoody?

The Patagonia is warmer for its weight. Its 800-fill down traps heat far better than the Big Chill's polyester fill. The Big Chill is bulkier and heavier at 1.2 lb but delivers less warmth per ounce.

Is the Patagonia worth $325 more than the Big Chill?

Only if you need real cold-weather performance. The Patagonia is lighter, warmer, and has a better shell and hood. If you want a casual coat for mild winter days, the $20.00 Big Chill at Poshmark covers that for far less.

Which has better sizing for plus sizes?

The Big Chill. It runs from S to 3X, including plus. The Patagonia Down Sweater Hoody is listed in a regular fit with standard women's sizing.

Which one handles rain better?

Neither is waterproof. The Patagonia has a PFC-free DWR finish that sheds light snow and drizzle. The Big Chill lists a plain polyester shell with no water-repellent finish stated.

Which packs smaller for travel?

The Patagonia. At 343 g (12.1 oz) with 800-fill down, it compresses into a small space. The Big Chill is a 1.2 lb mid-length puffer that takes up much more room.

Does the Big Chill have a warranty?

No. Its listing states no written warranty. Patagonia has a long-standing repair and returns program, which matters at the $345.00 price.

Big Chill Women's and Women's Plus Wide Quilted Puffer Coat with Faux Fur Trim Hood, Sizes S-3X vs Patagonia Women's Down Sweater Hoody

Buy the Patagonia Down Sweater Hoody if you want real warmth at low weight and will pay for it. Buy the Big Chill Wide Quilted Puffer if you want a warm-looking coat on a tight budget or need plus sizes up to 3X. As of November 3, 2026, the Big Chill is $20.00 at Poshmark and the Patagonia is $345.00 at Backcountry.com. That is a $325 gap, and the two coats are not close in materials or construction.

Today the Big Chill Women's and Women's Plus Wide Quilted Puffer Coat with Faux Fur Trim Hood, Sizes S-3X costs $325.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent