Big Chill Wide Quilted Puffer Coat vs Alva Womens Waterproof Trench Coat

Buy the Big Chill if you want warmth for cold, dry days and a hood that stays on. Buy the Alva if you face rain and wind and want one coat that looks smart. The Big Chill is a bulky quilted puffer with a faux fur hood, rated 4.4 from 1,817 ratings. The Alva is a waterproof, windproof trench with taped seams and a removable hood, rated 4.6 from 1,072 ratings. Owners of the Alva praise the fit and dry wear in heavy rain, but some say it runs large and the hood is big.

• Choose the Big Chill if you need a warm, roomy puffer for cold winter days and want sizes up to 3X.
• Choose the Alva if you need a waterproof, windproof coat for rain and want a smarter trench look.