- Which mirror is better for a rental apartment?
- The Black Over-The-Door mirror is the safer pick for a rental because it hangs on hooks with no nails or tools. The Over-the-Door Mirror also hangs on a door, but its wall-mount hardware means drilling if you use it that way.
- Which one has better ratings?
- The Over-the-Door Mirror Full Length: 4.9 out of 5 from 193 ratings versus 4.2 out of 5 from 13 ratings for the Black Over-The-Door mirror. The second mirror's sample is far larger, so its score is more reliable.
- Can either mirror hang on a wall?
- Only the Over-the-Door Mirror Full Length lists wall mounting, and it includes metal hanging hardware. The Black Over-The-Door mirror is door-hung only.
- Which mirror is bigger?
- The Black Over-The-Door mirror is slightly bigger at 50.5 x 14.2 in versus 49.5 x 13.5 in. The difference is about an inch in each direction, so both give a full head-to-toe view.
- Is the plastic frame a problem?
- PS plastic is lighter and cheaper than wood but feels less solid. The Over-the-Door Mirror offsets this with a 5 lb weight and a 4.9 rating across 193 reviews.
- Is one worth paying more for?
- Check the store prices on this page. If they are close, the Over-the-Door Mirror's higher rating, lighter weight and wall-mount option make it the easier choice.
- Which mirror suits a bathroom?
- The Over-the-Door Mirror Full Length lists the bathroom among its rooms and can be wall-mounted, which suits a bathroom better. The Black Over-The-Door mirror is built for hanging on a door in a bedroom, dorm or rental.
- Does the soft frame on the Over-the-Door Mirror matter?
- Its frame is upholstered flannelette over PS plastic, which the listing calls comfortable and safe for daily use. It is softer to the touch than the wood frame on the Black Over-The-Door mirror but less rigid.
- How hard is it to install the Over-the-Door Mirror?
- Owners say the hanger needs screws and a screwdriver, and a power drill makes it easier. The Black Over-The-Door mirror hangs on hooks with no tools.
- Which mirror is easier to hang on a door?
- The Black Over-The-Door mirror, because its hooks need no tools. Owners of the Over-the-Door Mirror report hangers that are a bit wide for some door thicknesses and could use more velcro at the top to stop tilt.