DealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Compare

Over-the-Door Mirror Full Length vs Door Mirror Full Length, 51 x 16 Inch Full Body Wall Mirror Over The Door Hanging Mirror

Buy the Over-the-Door Mirror Full Length if you want a decorative, upholstered wave-shaped mirror for a bedroom or closet door and prefer a smaller, lighter piece. Buy the Door Mirror Full Length 51 x 16 if you want the largest reflection, tempered shatterproof glass and an aluminum frame for a bathroom or a busy hallway. The Over-the-Door Mirror is rated 4.9 out of 5 from 193 ratings; no price was given for either mirror, so check current store prices on Deal.ai before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

O
Over-the-Door Mirror Full Length

Over-the-Door Mirror Full Length

4.9· 193 ratings

Choose the Over-the-Door Mirror Full Length if you want a soft upholstered frame, a wavy silhouette and a lighter 5 lb mirror that hangs on a door or wall in a bedroom or closet.

Pros
  • Soft upholstered frame is comfortable to brush against and safer around kids
  • Wave-shaped silhouette adds character to a plain door or wall
Light at 5 lb, so it is easy to lift and reposition
  • Hangs vertically or horizontally with the included metal hardware
  • Rated 4.9 out of 5 from 193 ratings
  • Cons
    • Plastic frame is less rigid and less durable than aluminum
    • Standard glass is not listed as shatterproof
    • Narrower 13.5 in width gives a tighter full-body view
    • No lighting
    D
    Door Mirror Full Length, 51 x 16 Inch Full Body Wall Mirror Over The Door Hanging Mirror

    Door Mirror Full Length, 51 x 16 Inch Full Body Wall Mirror Over The Door Hanging Mirror

    Choose the Door Mirror Full Length if you want a bigger 51 x 16 in reflection, tempered shatterproof glass and a rigid aluminum frame that suits a bathroom or a high-traffic hallway.

    Pros
    • Tempered shatterproof glass is the safer choice near a bathroom or busy hallway
    • Aluminum frame resists fading and holds its shape
    • Larger 51 x 16 in surface gives a wider full-body view
    • Can hang on a door or wall, or lean against a wall
    • Hook-and-loop fastener keeps it from banging against the door
    Cons
    • Plain rectangular look is less decorative
    • Heavier than the 5 lb Over-the-Door Mirror, so door mounting needs a solid door
    • Only black or white frame colors
    • No lighting

    What separates them

    Over-the-Door Mirror Full LengthDoor Mirror Full Length, 51 x 16 Inch Full Body Wall Mirror Over The Door Hanging Mirror
    GlassStandard glassTempered, shatterproof and explosion-proof glass
    Frame materialPS plastic with a black foil finish, upholstered flanneletteAluminum alloy, anti-faded
    Size49.5 x 13.5 in51 x 16 in
    Weight5 lbNot stated; aluminum frame and larger glass make it heavier
    ShapeIrregular wave-shaped rectanglePlain rectangle
    MountingDoor or wall, vertical or horizontal, metal hanging hardware includedDoor or wall hanging, or leaning; hook-and-loop fastener included
    ColorsBlack or goldBlack or white
    Best roomCloset or bathroom, bedroomBathroom, bedroom, living room, cloakroom

    Price history

    • Over-the-Door Mirror Full Length: lowest $7.32 on Nov 2 at Newegg.com.
    • Door Mirror Full Length, 51 x 16 Inch Full Body Wall Mirror Over The Door Hanging Mirror: lowest $51.43 on Nov 2 at Amazon.

    Prices at every store

    Over-the-Door Mirror Full Length

    • AmazonCheck price at Amazon
    • AmericanflatCheck price at Americanflat
    • eBayCheck price at eBay
    Prices and history →

    Door Mirror Full Length, 51 x 16 Inch Full Body Wall Mirror Over The Door Hanging Mirror

    • My StoreCheck price at My Store
    • AmazonCheck price at Amazon
    • WalmartCheck price at Walmart
    Prices and history →

    Specs compared

    SpecOver-the-Door Mirror Full LengthDoor Mirror Full Length, 51 x 16 Inch Full Body Wall Mirror Over The Door Hanging Mirror
    ShapeRectangle, RectangularRectangular
    Suitable RoomsCloset, Bathroom—
    Mounting LocationWall, Door—
    Body Part ShapeFull body—
    Height49.5 in—
    Width13.5 in—
    Weight5 lb—
    Installation TypeWall-mounted, Door-mounted—
    OrientationVertical, Horizontal—
    Hardware IncludedYes (metal hanging hardware pouch)—
    Lighting TypeNo lighting—
    Frame MaterialPS Plastic—
    Show all 25 specsShow fewer specs
    SpecOver-the-Door Mirror Full LengthDoor Mirror Full Length, 51 x 16 Inch Full Body Wall Mirror Over The Door Hanging Mirror
    Use CaseChecking outfit—
    MaterialGlass—
    ColorBlack, Gold—
    Frame TypeFramed—
    StyleModern, Contemporary—
    EmbellishmentContoured profile—
    FinishBlack foil finish—
    Design HighlightsFull-Length—
    Mirror Type—Bathroom Mirrors
    Color Type—

    Questions and answers

    Which mirror is better for a bathroom?
    The Door Mirror Full Length is the better bathroom pick. Its tempered shatterproof glass and aluminum frame handle moisture and knocks better than the plastic frame and standard glass of the Over-the-Door Mirror.
    Which gives a fuller body view?
    The Door Mirror Full Length. At 51 x 16 in it is taller and wider than the 49.5 x 13.5 in Over-the-Door Mirror, so you see more of your outfit at once.
    Is the Over-the-Door Mirror safe around kids?
    Its soft upholstered frame is gentler to bump into, but the glass is not listed as shatterproof. If safety is the priority, pick the Door Mirror Full Length with tempered glass.
    Which is easier to hang?
    The Over-the-Door Mirror weighs 5 lb and comes with metal hanging hardware for door or wall. The Door Mirror Full Length is larger and heavier but includes a hook-and-loop fastener to steady it against the door.
    Which lasts longer?
    The Door Mirror Full Length should last longer. Aluminum resists fading and warping better than the PS plastic frame on the Over-the-Door Mirror.
    Is one worth the extra cost?
    Compare live prices on Deal.ai first, since neither price was given here. If the two are close, the Door Mirror Full Length gives you more glass, tempered safety glass and a metal frame for the money.

    More comparisons

    • Black Over-The-Door Full-Length Mirror vs Over-the-Door Mirror Full Length
    • Black Over-The-Door Full-Length Mirror vs Door Mirror Full Length, 51 x 16 Inch Full Body Wall Mirror Over The Door Hanging Mirror

    Buying guides that pick them

    • Best over-the-door full-length mirrors
    Black
    Rec. Room—Bathroom
    Theme—Home Decor
    size—51 x 16