Over-the-Door Full Length Mirror vs DUMOS 47x14 Full Length Door Mirror

Both are slim over-the-door full-length mirrors at nearly the same size. The Americanflat wins on frame feel and a long, strong review record; its PS plastic frame is the weak point. The DUMOS wins on frame material with aluminum and shatter-resistant tempered glass, but has far fewer owner reports. Buy the Americanflat for a proven, easy install with a sturdier-looking frame; buy the DUMOS if you want metal and tempered glass and can accept less track record.

• Choose the Americanflat over-the-door mirror if you want a widely reviewed, easy-to-hang mirror and prefer a framed, contoured look.
• Choose the DUMOS 47x14 if you want an aluminum frame and tempered shatter-resistant glass in an arched shape.