Which is better for tough messes like grease or pet accidents?

The Brawny. Its 3-ply sheet is thicker and is marketed as 2X more durable than the leading store brand, so it holds up better on grease, stovetops and pet messes. The Bounty Essentials 2-ply sheet is fine for light spills.

Which is cheaper per sheet?

The Bounty. At $5.12 for 2 triple rolls of 108 sheets, it costs about 2.4 cents per sheet. The Brawny at $12.99 for 6 rolls of 114 sheets costs about 1.9 cents per sheet only if you count the full 684 sheets; per roll it is far more expensive upfront.

Does the Brawny really let you use less?

Yes. Tear-A-Square perforations give you a quarter, half or full sheet, so a small spill uses a fraction of a towel. The Bounty Select-A-Size only lets you shorten a sheet along its length.

Which lasts longer between shopping trips?

The Brawny pack. Six double rolls equal about 12 regular rolls, roughly double the Bounty pack's 6-regular-roll equivalent, so it lasts longer despite the higher price.

Is the Brawny worth the extra money?

Only if you deal with heavy or wet messes often. For light everyday wiping, the Bounty at $5.12 does the job for less than half the price.

Bounty Essentials Select-A-Size Paper Towels vs Brawny Tear-A-Square Paper Towels

Buy the Bounty Essentials if price is the deciding factor: $5.12 at Walmart as of November 6, 2026, versus $12.99 at CVS Pharmacy for the Brawny. Buy the Brawny Tear-A-Square if you want a thicker 3-ply sheet and quarter, half or full sheet sizing for small spills. The Bounty pack is roughly half the price per sheet, but the Brawny is the sturdier towel.

Today the Bounty Essentials Select-A-Size Paper Towels costs $7.87 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.