StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Carhartt A18 Beanie vs New Era 59FIFTY Atlanta Braves Fitted Hat

The Carhartt A18 is a cheap, warm, one-size rib-knit beanie that fits almost anyone and takes hard wear; the New Era 59FIFTY is a structured, fitted baseball cap in exact hat sizes, built for fans and flat-brim wearers. The A18 wins on versatility, stretch and easy care; the 59FIFTY wins on shape retention, team detail and a precise fit. Owners of the A18 praise the warmth and the patch, but some find the acrylic itchy and the hand-wash label annoying. The 59FIFTY is loved for its stiff crown and embroidered logos, though it is not warm and needs an exact size.

  • Choose the Carhartt A18 Beanie if you want one warm knit hat that fits any head, packs flat and survives daily winter wear.
  • Choose the New Era 59FIFTY if you want a structured fitted cap with team embroidery and a precise, shape-holding fit.

Prices

  • Carhartt A18 Beanie: $10.00 at Mercari (checked today)
  • New Era 59FIFTY Atlanta Braves Fitted Hat: $24.00 at Amazon (checked today)
  • Difference: the Carhartt A18 Beanie is $14.00 cheaper than the New Era 59FIFTY Atlanta Braves Fitted Hat today
Carhartt
Carhartt A18 Beanie

Carhartt A18 Beanie

4.7(188 ratings)
$10.00at MercariChecked 1 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Mercari
Pros
  • Warm rib knit covers ears and head
  • One size stretches to fit most adults
  • Folds flat into a pocket
  • Iconic workwear look with the Carhartt patch
  • Durable acrylic holds up to daily wear
Cons
  • Acrylic can feel itchy on sensitive skin
  • Care label says hand wash only
  • No structured shape, so it slouches
  • Limited color choice per listing
New Era
New Era 59FIFTY

New Era 59FIFTY Atlanta Braves Fitted Hat

New Era 59FIFTY

$24.00at AmazonChecked 1 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Amazon

Store links may earn us a commission. As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

Pros
  • Structured crown keeps its shape
  • Exact fitted sizing for a precise fit
  • Raised embroidered team logo and patch collage
  • Durable polyester that wipes clean
  • Official MLB licensed cap
Cons
  • No stretch, so the size must be right
  • No ear coverage and little warmth
  • Team-specific design limits everyday wear
  • Stiff crown and flat brim are not for everyone

What separates them

Carhartt A18 BeanieNew Era 59FIFTY Atlanta Braves Fitted Hat
FitOne size, stretch rib knit, 54-63 cm head circumferenceFitted in exact sizes from 7 to 8, no stretch
StructureSoft slouchy knit that folds into a pocketStiff structured crown and flat brim that hold their shape
WarmthFull ear and head coverage for winterNo ear coverage, thin polyester, all-season only
Material100% acrylic rib knit100% polyester
CareLabel says hand wash; some listings say machine washWipe clean with a damp cloth
Style detailSmall Carhartt patch on the fold-up cuffRaised embroidered team logo plus wrap-around commemorative patches
VersatilityPlain workwear look that goes with anythingTeam-specific look tied to one club

Price history

$44.99$10.00
Oct 31Nov 16
  • Carhartt A18 Beanie: lowest $10.00 on Nov 10 at Poshmark; $10.00 on Nov 16.
  • New Era 59FIFTY Atlanta Braves Fitted Hat: lowest $24.00 on Nov 16 at Amazon.

Prices at every store

Carhartt A18 Beanie

  • eBayNew

    In stock

    $10.99Checked 1 h ago
    Visit eBay
  • WalmartNew

    In stockSold by NIBY CORPReturns: Sold by a Walmart Marketplace seller; returns go to the seller under the seller's returns policy.

    $14.99Free shippingChecked 1 h ago
    Visit Walmart
  • DungareesNew

    In stock

    $12.99+ $7.95 shippingChecked 1 h ago
    Visit Dungarees
  • MercariNew

    Availability unknown

    $10.00Checked 1 h ago
    Visit Mercari

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 26 stores and price history →

New Era 59FIFTY Atlanta Braves Fitted Hat

  • NeweggNew

    In stock

    $34.62+ $4.99 shippingChecked 43 min ago
    Visit Newegg
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $24.00Free shippingChecked 1 h ago
    Visit Amazon
  • eBayNew

    Availability unknown

    $24.49Checked Nov 4
    Visit eBay
  • Southern Sportz StoreNew

    Availability unknown

    $25.95Checked Nov 4
    Visit Southern Sportz Store

Also available at

  • WalmartCheck price at Walmart

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

All 20 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecCarhartt A18 BeanieNew Era 59FIFTY Atlanta Braves Fitted Hat
Material100% acrylic rib knitPolyester
SizeRegular OS7 1/4
StyleBeanieFitted
SeasonWinterAll-Season
ColorPink GlowBlue
Hat styleBeanieBaseball Cap
Clothing sizeOne Size7 1/4
Fabric careMachine WashWipe clean with a damp cloth
BrandCarharttNew Era
GenderMaleMale
Model numberA18—
Cuff styleFold-up cuff with Carhartt patch—
Show all 26 specsShow fewer specs
SpecCarhartt A18 BeanieNew Era 59FIFTY Atlanta Braves Fitted Hat
Fit typeOne Size—
Care instructionsHand Wash Only—
Head circumference54 - 63—
LogoCarhartt logo patch on front—
Clothing size groupMen—
Age groupAdult—
size_hat—7 1/4
Sport—Baseball
Cap Size—7 5/8, 7 1/8, 7 3/8, 7 1/4, 7 7/8, 7 3/4, 7 1/2…
Color category

What reviewers say

Carhartt A18 Beanie

  • 4.7 / 5188 ratings

Owners treat the A18 as a dependable basic: warm enough for most winters, keeps its shape, and the patch holds up. Complaints center on the acrylic feel and the hand-wash requirement.

What people mention
  • WarmthPraisedOwners say it keeps ears warm on cold commutes and job sites.
  • Material feelMixedSome find the acrylic soft enough; others say it feels scratchy and less premium than wool.
  • FitMixedThe one-size cuff works for most, but larger heads report a snug fit.
  • DurabilityPraisedReviewers report it holds shape and color through a season or more of regular wear.

New Era 59FIFTY Atlanta Braves Fitted Hat

Owners of 59FIFTY caps generally rate the fit and build highly, and special-edition Braves designs draw praise for the embroidery and patchwork. The main complaints are the stiff break-in and the fixed sizing.

What people mention
  • FitPraisedBuyers say the 7 1/4 fits true to other 59FIFTY caps.
  • BuildPraisedOwners report the structured crown keeps its shape over time.
  • EmbroideryPraisedThe raised front logo and wrap-around patches get compliments for detail.
  • StiffnessMixedSome find the crown and flat brim stiff until broken in.

Questions and answers

Which is better for cold weather?
The Carhartt A18. It is a thick rib-knit beanie that covers the ears, while the 59FIFTY is a thin polyester cap with no ear coverage.
Which lasts longer?
Both hold up well. The 59FIFTY keeps its structured shape for years with wipe-clean care, while the A18 can stretch and pill over time with heavy washing.
Is the 59FIFTY worth stepping up to over the A18?
Only if you want a fitted, structured team cap. For warmth and one-size convenience, the A18 does more for less.
Can I wash the Carhartt beanie in a machine?
The official care label says hand wash only, though some listings say machine wash. Hand washing in cold water and air drying is the safe choice.
Does the 59FIFTY fit a large head?
Yes, it comes in sizes up to 8. Measure your head and pick the exact size, since the cap has no stretch.
Which is more versatile?
The A18. Its plain knit look works with any outfit, while the 59FIFTY is tied to one team's colors and logos.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Carhartt A18 Beanie vs Big Beanie
  • Carhartt A18 Beanie vs Stussy Checkerboard Cuff Beanie
  • Carhartt A18 Beanie vs CABLE EARMUFF BEANIE
  • Carhartt A18 Beanie vs Xiaomi Mi Baseball Cap
  • MEICHEN Unisex Beanie Winter Knitted Cuffed Soft Warm Hat for Men/Women Ski Watch Cap vs Carhartt A18 Beanie
  • XIAOCHA Mens Wind-Resistant Fleece Beanie Solid Slim Crown Outdoor Trek Fall Winter Cap vs Carhartt A18 Beanie
  • XIAOCHA Mens Wind-Resistant Fleece Beanie Solid Slim Crown Outdoor Trek Fall Winter Cap vs New Era 59FIFTY

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best Xiaomi hats
—
Black
Hat size—7 3/8
Theme—Latino culture
Items included—Hat
Count per pack—1