Carhartt A18 Beanie vs Cable Earmuff Beanie

The Carhartt A18 is the safer buy for anyone who wants a proven, hard-wearing knit that holds its shape and works with everything. The Cable Earmuff Beanie is the better pick if cold ears are your main complaint: its extended cable-knit profile covers more of the head and ears. The A18 has the longer track record and a bigger brand following; the cable beanie scores higher with owners and offers more warmth per wear. Build quality is close, but the A18's dense acrylic rib is the more durable of the two.

• Choose the Carhartt A18 if you want a durable, iconic rib-knit beanie that suits work sites, weekends and everyday wear.
• Choose the Cable Earmuff Beanie if you feel the cold in your ears and want a softer cable knit with extra coverage.