- Which is warmer, the Carhartt A18 or the Big Beanie?
- The Big Beanie has a small wool content (6%) plus nylon and polyurethane, which should feel denser. The A18 is 100% acrylic. Neither is a heavy winter hat; both are casual knit beanies.
- Which fits a bigger head?
- The A18 states a 54–63 cm head circumference, which covers most adults. The Big Beanie lists 50 cm circumference despite being marketed for XL and XXL sizes, so check the fit before buying.
- Is the Big Beanie worth $24 more than the A18?
- Only if the A18's one-size fit does not work for you. The Big Beanie's blend is more varied, but you pay $40.00 at a single store versus $15.99 at eBay.
- Which lasts longer?
- Hard to say from specs alone. The A18 is a simple acrylic rib knit that has been sold since 1987; the Big Beanie's nylon and polyurethane may resist stretching. Both need gentle care, and the A18 is hand wash only.
- Can I machine wash either one?
- The A18 says hand wash only. The Big Beanie does not state care instructions, so wash it by hand to be safe.
- Where can I buy each one?
- The A18 is priced new at 5 stores, with the best at $15.99 at eBay as of November 4, 2026. The Big Beanie is priced at 1 store, Oddjob® Hats, at $40.00 as of the same date.
