Charmin Essentials Soft Toilet Paper vs Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Toilet Paper

Buy Charmin Essentials Soft if you want more sheets per roll and a soft, clog-safe 2-ply at the lower end of the Charmin line. Buy Cottonelle Ultra Comfort if you want a thicker, cushier sheet and a brand with a strong comfort reputation. Charmin gives you more sheets per roll and more rolls per pack here, while Cottonelle's Ultra Comfort line is generally thicker and more absorbent per sheet. Owners of both rate them well; Charmin's 4.7 rating across more than 22,000 reviews shows broad satisfaction.

• Choose the Charmin Essentials Soft if you want the most sheets per roll and a septic-safe 2-ply that Roto-Rooter approves for clog-prone plumbing.
• Choose the Cottonelle Ultra Comfort if you prefer a thicker, plusher sheet and don't mind fewer sheets per roll.