Charmin Essentials Soft Toilet Paper vs Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper

Buy Quilted Northern Ultra Plush if softness is the priority: three plies, an embossed finish and a low-lint design make it the plusher roll, and owners rate it well. Buy Charmin Essentials Soft if you want a proven everyday roll with a huge review base and a reputation for clog-safe flushing. Charmin is 2-ply and thinner; Quilted Northern is the step up in feel, but its listing data is inconsistent on sheets per roll, so check the pack before you commit.

• Choose the Charmin Essentials Soft if you want a dependable 2-ply everyday roll backed by tens of thousands of ratings and Roto-Rooter approved clog safety.
• Choose the Quilted Northern Ultra Plush if you want the softest feel and least lint and are willing to pay more per sheet for three plies.