Charmin Ultra Soft Bath Tissue vs Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Toilet Paper

Both are 2-ply mega rolls with roughly similar sheet counts, so the choice comes down to feel and pack size. Charmin Ultra Soft is the softer, more absorbent sheet and is widely praised by owners for comfort; Cottonelle Ultra Comfort is a bit firmer, cleans well and comes in a larger 12-mega-roll pack that lasts longer between restocks. Buy Charmin for softness and sensitive skin; buy Cottonelle for a longer-lasting pack and a slightly stronger, more textured sheet.

• Choose the Charmin Ultra Soft if you want the softest sheet for everyday comfort and sensitive skin, and a compact 6-roll pack that fits small closets.
• Choose the Cottonelle Ultra Comfort if you want a bigger 12-mega-roll pack that lasts longer and a slightly firmer, more textured sheet for cleaning.