Which is softer, Quilted Northern Ultra Plush or Charmin Ultra Soft?

Quilted Northern Ultra Plush is 3-ply and marketed as its softest line. Charmin Ultra Soft is 2-ply but built around a smooth, lotion-free feel. Softness is personal, so try a small pack before committing to 24 rolls.

Which is cheaper per roll?

Quilted Northern Ultra Plush at $8.99 for 24 mega rolls at Blain's Farm & Fleet as of November 8, 2026 is far cheaper per roll than Charmin Ultra Soft at $14.76 for 6 mega rolls at eBay. The gap is roughly five times per roll.

Is the Charmin pack worth the extra cost?

Only if you value the small carton size or the larger review base. On price per sheet, the Quilted Northern pack wins clearly at the prices listed on November 8, 2026.

Are both septic safe?

Yes. Both are labeled septic safe for standard sewer and septic systems.

The Quilted Northern pack, by a wide margin. It has 24 rolls at 255 sheets each versus 6 rolls at 224 sheets each for the Charmin carton.

Which is better for sensitive skin?

Charmin Ultra Soft is labeled for sensitive skin and is unscented. Quilted Northern Ultra Plush is also unscented, but it does not carry a sensitive-skin label.

Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper vs Charmin Ultra Soft Bath Tissue

Both are 3-ply-class softness plays, but they differ in pack size and price per sheet. Quilted Northern Ultra Plush gives you 24 mega rolls at $8.99 at Blain's Farm & Fleet as of November 8, 2026, versus Charmin Ultra Soft's 6 mega rolls at $14.76 at eBay the same date. Buy Quilted Northern for volume and value; buy Charmin Ultra Soft if you want a smaller pack and a brand with a huge review base.

Today the Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper costs $5.77 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.