Which is better for hot sleepers?

The Eddie Bauer percale set. Percale's open weave is crisper and more breathable than the denser 550 thread count sateen of the Charter Club set.

Which fits a deep mattress?

The Charter Club set, with pockets rated to 18 inches versus 16 inches for the Eddie Bauer set.

Is the higher thread count worth it?

If you want a smoother, heavier feel, yes. If you want a crisp, cool sheet, the lower-count Eddie Bauer percale is the better match.

Both are 100% cotton. The Charter Club set has a much larger rating base at 4.4, which is the stronger durability signal here; the Eddie Bauer set sits at 3.7 from 135 ratings.

Are the Eddie Bauer sheets certified?

Yes. They carry OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certification. The Charter Club set lists no such certification.

Do the Eddie Bauer pillowcases stay on?

Yes. They use a side envelope closure, which tucks the pillow in. The Charter Club pillowcases are standard open-end.

Charter Club Damask 550 Thread Count Sheet Set vs Eddie Bauer Peached Percale Sheet Set

Buy the Charter Club Damask set if you want a smooth, heavier sateen-feel cotton sheet with a high thread count and deep 18-inch pockets. Buy the Eddie Bauer Peached Percale set if you prefer a crisp, breathable percale weave and OEKO-TEX certified cotton. The Charter Club set has a much larger rating base (4.4 from 13,000 ratings) versus the Eddie Bauer set (3.7 from 135 ratings).

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.