Which is better for hot sleepers?

The Peached Percale. Percale is a plain, crisp weave that breathes, while the Canoe Lake set is flannel, which traps warmth.

Which fits a thicker mattress?

The Peached Percale, at up to 16 inches deep. The Canoe Lake set tops out at 15 inches.

Is the higher thread count worth it?

Not by itself. The gap is 180 versus 200, which is small. Feel and warmth matter more here than the count.

Both are 100% cotton and machine washable. Flannel tends to pill and thin with heavy washing, so the percale set may hold up longer with regular use.

Which is better for winter?

The Canoe Lake Paddle flannel set. Its brushed surface feels warmer against the skin on cold nights.

Do both come as 4-piece sets?

Yes. Both are 4-piece sets with deep pockets.

Eddie Bauer Peached Percale Sheet Set vs Eddie Bauer Canoe Lake Sheet Set

Both are Eddie Bauer cotton sheet sets, but they are built for different sleepers. The Peached Percale set is a 180-thread-count percale with 16-inch deep pockets, a crisp, cool feel, and a 3.7 rating from 135 ratings. The Canoe Lake Paddle set is a 200-thread-count cotton flannel with a 5 rating from 2,100 ratings and 15-inch pockets, so it suits cold sleepers and thicker mattresses up to 15 inches. Pick by feel and mattress depth, not by the star gap alone.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.