Which is better for everyday work carry?

The Brooklyn 28. It fits a tablet, a water bottle and a full-size wallet, and the wide 10.5" strap sits comfortably on the shoulder. The Nolita 19 is too small for that load.

Which holds a phone, cards and keys better?

The Nolita 19. It has credit card slots and an inner pocket, and the zipper keeps everything enclosed. The Brooklyn 28 has one snap pocket and an open top.

Is the Nolita 19 worth stepping up to if I already have a big tote?

Yes, if you want a second, small bag for evenings and quick errands. It covers a different job than a large leather shoulder bag rather than replacing it.

Natural grain leather on the Brooklyn 28 ages and softens but needs care against rain and scuffs. Coated canvas on the Nolita 19 resists moisture and stains but can show wear at the edges over time.

Can the Brooklyn 28 be worn crossbody?

No. It is a shoulder bag with a 10.5" drop and no crossbody strap. The Nolita 19 is also a shoulder bag, with a 6.25" drop plus a wrist strap.

Which is better for travel?

The Nolita 19 for a light day bag, since it is compact and zips shut. The Brooklyn 28 holds more but its open magnetic top is less secure in crowds.

Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag vs Coach Nolita 19 Signature Canvas

These are two very different Coach bags, not two versions of one. The Brooklyn 28 is a full-size hobo in natural grain leather, big enough for a tablet, water bottle and daily load, with a wide strap that sits comfortably on the shoulder. The Nolita 19 is a small coated-canvas shoulder bag that holds a phone, cards and keys and little else. Buy the Brooklyn 28 for capacity and leather; buy the Nolita 19 for a light, compact bag for evenings and quick errands.

Choose the Brooklyn 28 if you want one leather shoulder bag that carries a full day's essentials and gets softer with wear.
Choose the Nolita 19 if you want a small, light signature-canvas bag for phone, cards and keys, day or evening.

Prices

Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag: $128.99 at eBay (checked today)
Coach Nolita 19 Signature Canvas: $109.00 at Coach Outlet (checked today)
Difference: the Coach Nolita 19 Signature Canvas is $19.99 cheaper than the Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag today

	Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag	Coach Nolita 19 Signature Canvas
Size	11" L x 11" H x 3.25" W, a full-size hobo	7.5" L x 4.5" H x 2" W, compact
Material	Natural grain leather with visible texture and a soft hand	Signature coated canvas with leather trim
Closure	Magnetic snap, quick to open but not secure	Zipper, keeps contents enclosed
Strap	Wide shoulder strap with 10.5" drop	6.25" drop with wrist strap and top handle options
Organization	One inside snap pocket	Credit card slots plus an inner pocket
Weight	Leather body carries more weight	Lightweight canvas, easy to carry all day
Style range	Minimalist everyday shoulder bag	Day-to-night, including evenings out

Spec	Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag	Coach Nolita 19 Signature Canvas
color	—	White
actual_color	—	Sand Chalk
pattern	—	Let It Snow Motif
size	—	7 1/2" (L) x 4 1/2" (H) x 2" (W)
Closure	—	Zipper
Manufacturer Color	—	Gold/Sand/Chalk
Hardware Color	—	Gold/Brass
Carrying Style	—	Wrist Strap, Shoulder Strap, Top Handle
Depth (")	—	2.0
Material	—	Leather, Canvas
Gender	—	Female
Width (")	—	7.5

Spec	Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag	Coach Nolita 19 Signature Canvas
Height (")	—	4.5
Handle Drop (")	—	6.25

Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag vs Coach Nolita 19 Signature Canvas

Prices

Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag vs Coach Nolita 19 Signature Canvas

Prices

Coach Nolita 19 Signature Canvas

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store