Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag vs Coach Super Soft Large Carryall Satchel
The Brooklyn Shoulder Bag is the better pick for most shoppers: a soft woven-leather hobo with a wide 10.5-inch strap drop, a magnetic snap, and an interior slip pocket, rated 4.5 from 581 ratings. The Super Soft Large Carryall Satchel is the step up if you want a large, zip-top leather carryall that holds more and closes securely. Owners praise the Brooklyn's soft leather and comfortable strap, but some question the leather against the price and find it too small for a laptop and books. The Satchel's sparse listing leaves its size and weight unconfirmed, so check it in person if capacity matters.
- Choose the Brooklyn Shoulder Bag if you want a soft, lightweight shoulder hobo that works day to night and carries daily essentials without bulk.
- Choose the Super Soft Large Carryall Satchel if you need a large leather bag with a secure zip top and room for more than the basics.
Prices
- Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag: $155.50 at eBay (last seen Nov 9)
- Coach Super Soft Large Carryall Satchel: $750.00 at COACH (checked today)
- Difference: the Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag is $594.50 cheaper than the Coach Super Soft Large Carryall Satchel at the latest prices (Nov 9 and Nov 16)

