Columbia Bugaboot III vs Ecetana Snow Boots for Women

The Columbia Bugaboot III is the serious winter boot of the two: seam-sealed waterproof leather, 200g insulation, a molded shell and a temperature rating to -25°F, backed by hundreds of owner reviews. The Ecetana is a lighter women's fashion-leaning snow boot with faux fur lining and a ridged rubber sole, with only a small review base. Buy the Columbia for real cold, deep snow and winter hiking; buy the Ecetana for casual winter walking where warmth and looks matter more than hard use.

• Choose the Columbia Bugaboot III if you face deep snow, sub-freezing days or winter hiking and snowshoeing, and want a proven waterproof leather boot with a real cold rating.
• Choose the Ecetana if you want a warm, faux-fur-lined women's boot for everyday winter walking and light outdoor use, and you prefer a softer, more casual look.