Which is better for snowshoeing and winter hiking?

The Columbia Bugaboot III. Buyers specifically praise its grip on snowy inclines and use it for snowshoeing, and it is rated to -25°F. The Chilkat V is lighter and more cushioned, which helps on long walks but gives up some weight advantage in deep snow.

Is the Columbia Bugaboot III worth saving $25 over the Chilkat V?

Yes for most shoppers. At $120 versus $145, the Columbia adds a published -25°F rating and strong snow traction. Pay the extra for the North Face only if lighter weight and a softer midsole matter more to you.

Which boot lasts longer?

The Chilkat V has fewer durability complaints. Some Columbia buyers report the rubber shell cracking at the seams over time. The North Face adds rustproof hardware, which helps in wet, salted conditions.

The Columbia Bugaboot III runs very small and snug; buyers advise sizing up. The Chilkat V comes in whole sizes only, so try your usual size and check the fit before a long trip.

Both use 200g insulation. The Columbia publishes a -25°F / -32°C rating, while the North Face does not state one. Some Columbia buyers still find it marginal in extreme cold, so add wool socks either way.

Which is better for wide feet?

The Columbia Bugaboot III. Buyers with wide, flat feet report it works well, though the snug fit means sizing up. The Chilkat V has no comparable feedback on width.

Columbia Bugaboot III vs The North Face Chilkat V Lace-Up

Both are 200g-insulated, waterproof, seam-sealed men's winter boots with rubber shells and grippy outsoles. The Columbia Bugaboot III is the better value: $120 at Zappos.com as of November 8, 2026 versus $145 at Backcountry.com for the Chilkat V. Pick the Columbia for cold, snowy hiking and snowshoeing on a budget; pick the North Face if you want a lighter, more cushioned boot with recycled materials and rustproof hardware. The Columbia is the safer buy for most shoppers, but it runs small, so size up.

Today the Columbia Bugaboot III costs $25.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.