Corelle Mystic Gray 12-Piece Dinnerware Set vs Corelle Cherish Square 16-Piece Dinnerware Set

Both are Corelle Vitrelle glass sets for four, so the real choice is shape and piece count. The Cherish Square gives you 16 pieces including a dessert bowl and a 22 oz bowl, plus a 5-year warranty and up to 80% recycled glass content. The Mystic Gray gives you 12 pieces with a soft gray banded look and a lighter, more compact stack. Owners of both praise the light weight and chip resistance; the Mystic Gray's main complaint is color that reads slightly green, and the Cherish's square corners take a little more care to nest.

• Choose the Mystic Gray if you want a neutral gray pattern and a smaller, lighter 12-piece set that stacks in half the space of ceramic.
• Choose the Cherish Square if you want more pieces per setting, bigger bowls, a square white look and a 5-year warranty.