Which is better for carpet?

The PowerMax. Its 100 air watts and 11-inch brush roll agitate and lift carpet pile; the Simpli-Stik's 8.5 air watts is meant for surface debris on rugs and hard floors.

Is the Simpli-Stik enough as my only vacuum?

For an apartment with mostly hard floors and low-pile rugs, yes. For wall-to-wall carpet, pet hair or stairs, it lacks the suction and reach of the PowerMax.

Both are budget Dirt Devil models with plastic bodies. The PowerMax carries a 1-year limited warranty; the Simpli-Stik's rinseable filter lowers running cost, but neither is built for a decade of heavy use.

Is the PowerMax worth the extra $23?

Yes if you clean carpet regularly. At $57.97 versus $34.99, you get roughly twelve times the air watts, a wider brush roll and a hose with wand.

Which is easier to carry upstairs?

The Simpli-Stik at 3.74 lb. The PowerMax weighs 12 lb, so plan to leave it on the main floor or use its hose for stairs.

No. Both are bagless with empty-and-rinse dirt cups; the PowerMax uses a cartridge filter and the Simpli-Stik a replaceable F113 filter.

Dirt Devil PowerMax Upright Vacuum vs Dirt Devil Simpli-Stik Stick Vacuum

Buy the PowerMax UD70111V if you have carpets or a mix of carpet and hard floor; its 100 air watts and 11-inch brush roll do real cleaning. Buy the Simpli-Stik only for quick hard-floor and rug touch-ups, where its 3.74 lb weight and 16 ft cord make it easy to grab. On price, the PowerMax is $57.97 at Walmart and the Simpli-Stik is $34.99 at Amazon, both as of November 6, 2026.

Today the Dirt Devil Simpli-Stik Stick Vacuum costs $22.98 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.