Donna Sharp Cabin Raising Pine Cone Quilt vs Donna Sharp Lodge Square Quilt Set King

Both are Donna Sharp king quilts in a lodge theme, so the choice comes down to coverage and what's in the box. The Cabin Raising quilt is larger, all-cotton on the face with a cotton-rich fill, and prewashed to resist shrinking. The Lodge Square set bundles a quilt with two shams, but its quilt is shorter and its fabric blend is not spelled out. Buy the Cabin Raising for a thick, roomy cotton quilt on a tall or deep mattress; buy the Lodge Square set if you want matching shams included and a blue, red and brown palette.

• Choose the Cabin Raising Pine Cone quilt if you want the bigger quilt, an all-cotton face and a heavyweight feel for a tall or deep king bed.
• Choose the Lodge Square 3-piece set if you want shams included and a multicolor blue, red and brown lodge look.