Which is better for a cold bedroom?

The Donna Sharp quilt is the warmer choice. It uses thick, dense heavyweight cotton with a 70/30 cotton-poly fill, while the Blue Lodge set is described as lightweight.

Does the Donna Sharp quilt come with shams?

No. It includes one king quilt only. Coordinating shams and pillows are sold separately, so add their cost before comparing. The Blue Lodge set includes two shams.

Is the Donna Sharp quilt worth the extra money?

Only if you want heavyweight prewashed cotton and the pine cone design. At $432.61 versus $52.99, you pay about eight times more and still buy shams separately.

Which fits a Cal king bed?

The Blue Lodge set is sold as King/Cal King and measures 110 by 96 inches. The Donna Sharp quilt is 108 by 98 inches, close in size but sold as King only.

Which is easier to care for?

The Donna Sharp quilt is prewashed to resist shrinking and fading. The Blue Lodge set is machine washable cold and tumble dry low, but you must not iron it.

Which has more reliable reviews?

The Blue Lodge set has 711 ratings averaging 4.7 out of 5. The Donna Sharp quilt has a perfect 5 out of 5 but from only 17 ratings, a much smaller sample.

Blue Lodge Quilt Set - King/Cal King vs Donna Sharp Cotton King Quilt - Cabin Raising Pine Cone Lodge - 108x98

Buy the Blue Lodge Quilt Set for a complete, affordable king set with two shams at $52.99. Buy the Donna Sharp Cabin Raising Pine Cone Lodge quilt only if you want a heavyweight, prewashed cotton lodge quilt and will pay $432.61 for the quilt alone. The price gap is roughly eight times, and the Donna Sharp set does not include shams.

Ask our shopping agent