Lodge Living Quilt Set vs Donna Sharp Cotton King Quilt - Cabin Raising Pine Cone Lodge - 108x98
Buy the Donna Sharp if you want a heavyweight cotton quilt that will last and you sleep on a king bed. Buy the Lodge Living if you want a full/queen set with two matching shams included and a lower price. The Donna Sharp King quilt has a recorded price of $432.61 as of November 1, 2026. No current price was given for the Lodge Living set.
Ask our shopping agent
Lodge Living Quilt Set
5Choose the Lodge Living Quilt Set if you need a full/queen quilt with two matching shams in the box and a wildlife print at a lower price.
Pros
- Two shams included, so the bed is dressed in one purchase
- OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified
- Reversible, with a wildlife print on both sides
- Available in full/queen and king
Cons
- Polyester face and microfiber back feel less breathable than cotton
- Not prewashed, so expect some shrinkage
- Only 3 ratings
What separates them
| Lodge Living Quilt Set | Donna Sharp Cotton King Quilt - Cabin Raising Pine Cone Lodge - 108x98 | |
|---|---|---|
| Material | 100% polyester patchwork face with microfiber back | 100% cotton cover, 70% cotton/30% polyester fill |
| Size | 90 x 90 in (full/queen); king option 105 x 95 in | 108 x 98 in king only |
| Shams included | Two matching shams included | Shams and pillows sold separately |
| Construction | Lightweight microfiber | Heavyweight, thick, dense cotton |
| Shrink and fade | Not prewashed | Prewashed to prevent shrinking and fading |
| Certification | OEKO-TEX Standard 100 | Not stated |
| Design | Red, brown and black woodland wildlife, pine cones and paw prints | Brown pine cones around a diamond centerpiece |
Price history
$432.61$99.99
- Lodge Living Quilt Set: lowest $99.99 on Nov 1 at Cabin Place.
- Donna Sharp Cotton King Quilt - Cabin Raising Pine Cone Lodge - 108x98: lowest $432.61 on Nov 1 at The Home Depot; $432.61 on Nov 2.
Prices at every store
Lodge Living Quilt Set
- Cabin PlaceCheck price at Cabin Place
- The Cabin PlaceCheck price at The Cabin Place
- Little Red General StoreCheck price at Little Red General Store
Donna Sharp Cotton King Quilt - Cabin Raising Pine Cone Lodge - 108x98
- The Home DepotCheck price at The Home Depot
Specs compared
| Spec | Lodge Living Quilt Set | Donna Sharp Cotton King Quilt - Cabin Raising Pine Cone Lodge - 108x98 |
|---|---|---|
| Material | microfiber | Cotton |
| Quilt dimensions | 90" x 90" | — |
| Sham dimensions | 20" x 26" | — |
| Set contents | one quilt and two matching shams | — |
| Reversible | reversible | — |
| Certification | OEKO-TEX Standard 100 | — |
| Bed size | Full / Queen | — |
| Color | Red / Black | — |
| Cover material | — | 100% Cotton |
| Fill material | — | 70% Cotton/30% Polyester |
What reviewers say
Lodge Living Quilt Set
Reception is very limited: 3 ratings averaging 5 out of 5. There is not enough feedback yet to judge long-term durability or color fastness.
Pros
- Overall rating of 5 out of 5 from 3 ratings
Donna Sharp Cotton King Quilt - Cabin Raising Pine Cone Lodge - 108x98
The quilt holds a 5 out of 5 rating from 17 ratings. That is a small sample, but nothing in it flags a common defect.
Pros
- Rustic pine cone design as pictured
- Heavy, substantial cotton feel
- Good size coverage on a king bed
Cons
- Small number of ratings limits confidence
- Matching shams cost extra
Questions and answers
- Which is better for a cold bedroom?
- The Donna Sharp. Its heavyweight cotton and cotton-rich fill trap more warmth than the Lodge Living's polyester and microfiber.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Donna Sharp. Thick, prewashed cotton resists shrinking and fading, while thin microfiber tends to pill and wear sooner.
- Is the Donna Sharp worth the extra money?
- If you have a king bed and want a durable cotton quilt, yes. If you need shams included or a full/queen size, the Lodge Living set covers more for less.
- Does the Lodge Living set fit a king bed?
- Yes, in the king option. That quilt measures 105 x 95 in and comes with two 36 x 20 in shams.
- Which is better for someone with allergies?
- The Lodge Living carries OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certification, which tests for harmful substances. The Donna Sharp lists no such certification.
- Can I put either quilt in the washing machine?
- Both are cotton or microfiber and machine washable on cold. The Donna Sharp is prewashed, so it is less likely to shrink on the first wash.
More comparisons
- Woodland Sage Bear & Moose Quilt Bed Set - King vs Donna Sharp Cotton King Quilt - Cabin Raising Pine Cone Lodge - 108x98
- Blue Lodge Quilt Set - King/Cal King vs Donna Sharp Cotton King Quilt - Cabin Raising Pine Cone Lodge - 108x98
- Lodge Living Quilt Set vs Woodland Sage Bear & Moose Quilt Bed Set - King
- Blue Lodge Quilt Set - King/Cal King vs Lodge Living Quilt Set