Don't Rain On My Puffer Jacket vs On The Move Hooded Fitted Puffer Coat

Both are hooded polyester puffers with plus sizes, so the real split is fit and fabric. The Don't Rain On My Puffer Jacket is a roomier, high-neck zip-front puffer in black, chocolate or white; the On The Move coat is a fitted nylon shell in four colors including burgundy and hunter green. Owners rate the Don't Rain On My Puffer Jacket well at 4.3 from about 2,000 ratings, and the fitted cut of the On The Move is the deciding factor for layering. Buy the On The Move if you want a trimmer silhouette; buy the Don't Rain On My Puffer Jacket if you want more room to layer a sweater.

• Choose the Don't Rain On My Puffer Jacket if you want a roomier high-neck puffer with a hood and a strong owner rating record.
• Choose the On The Move Hooded Fitted Puffer Coat if you want a closer-fitting nylon shell in burgundy or hunter green.