Snow Or Shine Hooded Puffer Jacket vs Don't Rain On My Puffer Jacket

The Snow Or Shine is the more adjustable jacket: a removable hood, cinched waist and bungee details let you tune the fit and block wind. The Don't Rain On My Puffer is the simpler, better-reviewed pick, with a 4.3 average from about 2,000 ratings and a high neck under a fixed hood. Both use polyester fill and lining, so warmth is similar; the Snow Or Shine's nylon shell sheds light rain better than the Don't Rain's all-polyester build. Buy the Snow Or Shine for a shaped, cinchable fit; buy the Don't Rain for a plain zip-front puffer with a track record.

• Choose the Snow Or Shine if you want a removable hood, a cinched waist and bungee adjustment, and a nylon shell for light rain.
• Choose the Don't Rain On My Puffer if you want a straightforward zip-front hooded puffer with a high neck and a large base of owner ratings.