Which is better for standing all day?

The Dr. Martens Polley. It has a cushioned AirWair sole, a slip-resistant outsole and a secure buckle strap. The Justina lists cushioning and stability but no slip rating.

The Polley. Its Goodyear welt sews the upper to the sole, so it can be resoled, and the leather is firm and finished. The Justina's construction is not specified.

Is the Justina worth the extra money?

Only if you need a pointed-toe formal flat. At $126.00 versus $119.95, the gap is small, but the Polley offers more durability features for less.

Which is better for wide feet?

Both list medium width. The Polley's round toe and adjustable buckle give more room. The Justina's pointed toe runs narrow.

Can I wear the Polley to the office?

Yes for casual workplaces. The black leather T-strap reads smart-casual. For formal dress codes, the Justina fits better.

Do both come in black?

Yes. The Polley is listed in black, and the Justina comes in black plus beige, silver and pink.

Dr. Martens Women's Polley vs Stuart Weitzman Justina Mary Jane

Buy the Dr. Martens Polley if you want a durable, slip-resistant everyday Mary Jane with a cushioned AirWair sole and a lower price. Buy the Stuart Weitzman Justina if you want a dressier pointed-toe flat for work or formal wear. The Polley is $119.95 at eBay as of November 7, 2026; the Justina's lowest recent price was $126.00 on November 3, 2026.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.