Which is better for wearing to an office?

The Stuart Weitzman Justina, with its pointed toe and formal leather finish, reads dressier. The Dr. Martens Polley is casual and better suited to jeans and everyday wear.

The Dr. Martens Polley. Its Goodyear-welted construction and rubber outsole are built for hard wear; the Justina is a lighter formal flat with no rubber outsole listed.

Is the Dr. Martens Polley worth the extra over the Justina?

It is actually cheaper: $119.95 at eBay as of November 7, 2026, versus $129.99 for the Justina. You get a welted, slip-resistant shoe for less money.

Which is better for travel and walking?

The Polley, thanks to its AirWair cushioned sole, slip-resistant rubber outsole and buckle strap that stays put. It weighs 1 lb 7.1 oz per shoe, so pack accordingly.

Does the Justina come in more colors?

Yes. The Justina comes in beige, silver, pink and black. The Polley listing shows black only.

Which is better for summer?

Both are listed for summer, but the Justina also covers spring and fall. The Polley's breathable leather lining helps in warm weather.

Stuart Weitzman Justina Mary Jane vs Dr. Martens Women's Polley

Buy the Dr. Martens Polley if you want a durable, slip-resistant everyday Mary Jane with a cushioned AirWair sole; buy the Stuart Weitzman Justina if you want a dressier pointed-toe flat for work or formal wear. The Polley is the better value: $119.95 at eBay as of November 7, 2026, versus $129.99 for the Justina. The Justina has only one recorded price point, so there is no history to judge a deal against.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.